So last night my band had an outdoor show. It was very hot and humid. I was playing my Amer standard P bass with TI JF an old set at least 5-6 years old. I use the same bass and tuner a clip on type to tune. I was checking the tuning all night. During the night I heard a few weird overtones coming from the band during songs. They were really nothing and the crowd never knew but they bothered me. Late in the set the band leaser told me to check my tuning it was off. ..by my tuner it was not. He checked his allot no problems with his. I i have never had this issue with my band and we use the same gear every show. The last song of the night was the Elvis version of Proud Mary where we really hit it hard and keep it moving. I was diggin in hard in the first posistion and the bandleader thought I was playing the wrong cord but was not. Hhe heard me flat F instead of F# I showed him and he shrugged it off. He told me I sounded flat allot tonight. The drummer said only when I played G or F#(1st posistion) it sounded funny like a weird harmonic tone...something weird. Could it be the strings? I have had a love hate relationship wit TIs but on this P bass they sound great. I checked intonation at the gig after our show and it was right on. Maybe the heat was a factor or while digging in I was bending the strings? I'm baffled by this and will check all my equipment. There are allot of TI lovers and haters so maybe somebody has an idea..maybe not. Thanks.
Strange. TIs have silk wrapping all the way through the string to prevent that from happening, not to say it could still happen in the right (or wrong) setting. If your tuner is chromatic and and can be adjusted, be sure it is set for 440 standard tuning. Mine was accidently knocked off of 440 tuning once and gave me a real sonic headache throughout the whole performance one night. Also, if you have not done so in a while, intonate the neck (or have it done if you do not know how by a competent tech) so it will be in tune all the way up the neck. This can cause similar problems. You may also had a string that got twisted when putting them on. take each string off the tuning peg and put them back on, retighten, and retune. If none of this helps, I am stumped...
Try a different set of strings and see what happens. It could have been frequencies from another instrument or a reflection or something else interfering with the bass, but it's pretty much impossible to say.
Thanks guys. We were playing in an open covered area allot of wood and stee supports and I know at outdoor shows sound can get funny. I never thought to check if the tuner is in 440..good one! I can try anoter set of strings which are Chromes. Besides the one set of TI's all my basses wear chromes.
There have been a lot of solar flare carona activity lately, keep that in mind. Seriously, TIs are well made strings and no reason they would be prone to going out of tune more than any other string. Re-wrap the string around the post of the tuner to make sure there is no slack.
Agree^ I think it was the heat and me playing hard.I was using a new rig only second time using and still dilaing in the tone but that IMO was not the issue.
I have a new chromatic tuner I've been using and I just noticed today it said "A 442" I'm like "***"??? So check that.
I did the snark defaults back to 440 So its not that. I will check it again..the BL is getting old ya know
TIs are low tension strings, right? That's been my experience. Thus, they are easily bent when played hard, so it's easy to see that others might hear them as "out of tune."
+1 When I play that funny thing called a guitar I can't play light strings, I end up fretting chords out of tune and overbending every little note when I really get going.
That is my thought also since the tuner is ok. I have had notes fart out some in the past while diggin hard up the neck but this was F# G in the first posisition and that is what had me puzzled. It was hot that night the strings might of relaxed more and I was playing pretty hard. I might restring it with Chromes but love the TI's on this bass and fear taking them off will damage them. That set is 5-6 years old and has been on at least 5 diff basses.
If there put on correct, and streached. There should be no problem. I have a 6 year old set that stays in tune fine. Weather is not an issue.
Hmmm strange that other band members thought you were flat. If anything you would be pulling the notes sharp. What about pickup height? If the pickup is too high that can give you some odd overtones. I played a hot outdoor gig this month with a P and TI flats, all was well.
Whenever I play outside where there's a lot of humidity, my bass neck usually bows a little which will make the lower strings go more flat than the higher. And after tuning (which adds more tension on the neck), it will bow more.
Went to a bass with chromes last night no issues and it was hot and humid. I'm just starting to think it was a weird unknown issue but thanks for the replies.
My guess is it's because the strings are 5-6 years old and have been on a number of different basses. Probably time to buy a new set. Strings can last a long time but not forever.