Lord help me, I like a One Direction song!

Ha! These guys don't have to be fat and old to be a joke. lol

 

Maybe if they learned some instruments I wouldn't be so hard on them.

 

Yeah... me too.

 

Hi,

You know, that's not too bad. I don't really understand why the halftime chorus but the theme of the song is cool and it's a simple little feel-good song. I wonder if the crowds will line dance to it?

Note: My 15 year old daughter absolutely loathes 1D.


Thank you for your indulgence,

BassCliff

 

and WHO do you think WROTE that song?

a fat and old married man whose kids think he's a joke! but they enjoy living a privileged life hehe

 

Gary Glitter from 1972 called. He wants his drums back. . Just kidding. Like what you like.

 

LOL -maybe not.. but I'd bet they're kicking your butt when it comes to take home pay !!

 

better living through chemistry ............ just sayin

 

Yeah, got that right! lol. Their "career" is fueled by teenage girls, and everything they do in the music industry is all based on sales. IMO it's not really music if you put absolutely no effort into it. If you didn't actually write the song, it probably means nothing to you... Music just has no feeling when it's all based on sales IMO.

(Current music industry = Sh!t)

 

Imagine that.

(Yes I understand that the Beatles were fantastic musicians and I love them to death, but I don't feel like teenage girls being fans is a good reason to dislike One Direction)

 

There were plenty of men who love/loved the Beatles, but there aren't many guys who like 1D.

 

When I do my acoustic shows, i sometimes play "I Want It That Way" by the Backstreet Boys. Yeah, the lyrics suck (and I'm a lyrics guy), but it's actually a fun song to play. Few people play it, but everyone knows it.

 

Haha man, One Direction is no where near The Four Top's level.
And it's not because they don't play instruments, it's because they have no soul when it comes to their music. It's like their just singing because of the money, not because they love it. Also, anything my 14 year old sister listens to just tells me right off the back that it's nothing special! (No offense!)

 

Every thread has a winner, and on this thread, YOU ARE IT.

 

Yay!!! Haha

 

BIB.
Songwriting credits are listed in order, much the same as food Ingredients on a packet.
They list writers in order of amount of work contributed.
Most of these songs that 1D have "written" have about 5 other people listed before any of the band members. That speaks volumes to how much they actually worked on each song.
It might be a few lyrics, it might be a few vocal melodies, it might just be the title. Either way, to say that they wrote "most of the album" is drawing a fairly long bow.