What's the most disturbing or creepy song you've ever heard? The song "Dying in New Brunswick" by Thursday definately gives me the chills whenever I hear it. I read in an interview with the singer Geoff that he wrote this song about a girlfriend of his who got raped. Apparently they were together for 4 years and his girlfriend moved to New Brunswick, NJ and was raped on her first week in town. After the incident she moved away and they never spoke again. The lines of the song "You hide your face because they don't believe it's true" and "And every night when I try to sleep I feel your hands all over my body" really freak me out.