Alright guys and gals, this thread is less about the basses in question and more about the emotional baggage that follows a bass you've had for 3 years... I have an American Deluxe J that has been faithful for 3 years but, especially in the last year or two, just hasn't felt "right". I'm a passive guy, for one. Secondly, the 22 frets and smaller body don't balance the way my P bass does. The list goes on. It's still a killer bass. But my local shop just got a 2004 or so American J, with S1 switch. Sunburst/rosewood, just like mine. Sounds terrific, feels extremely solid, and is immaculate. I'm considering a straight up 1 for 1 trade, and getting a hardshell case out of it. Obviously I want your opinion on the deal, but more than anything, I know I'll regret parting with this guy. Thoughts?