NCD?.sort of.. Schroeder/JBL content.

Discussion in 'Amps and Cabs [BG]' started by Kirk Bryant, Dec 28, 2014.

  1. So I read all the old threads re: how JBL 2225 speakers are lousy MI bass speakers already including the one that Bill Fitz. Had a few comments in. The general consensus is don't bother, however, I already had a Schroeder 115L that has been gathering dust for a few yrs I blew the 8Ohm Neo 15 out of.
    I have a friend who has tonnage and I brought the cab to him and we dropped one in. Now this has a modern JBL re cone that he told me was an updated higher power Version and supposedly a bit wider freq. range it's also lightly doped. Now having nothing to lose and possibly something to gain as it is 4Ohms now I said lets do this!
    So we loaded it up and low and behold it kicked arse! This cab does have a Bullet tweeter so not total low end. I'm sure there is a gap in the mids but man, I pounded that thing with the BX 500 and it took a lickin and kept on tickin. Yes of course it's old school but so am I.
    Honestly I was very pleasantly surprised. After running it through the wringer. I said I've gotta take this to work tonite and I did. To fill the gap in the mids I added a Aggie SL 112 (I think) on top and it kicked and we played both soft and loud sets and I dug it and if it sounds good it is good haha. Bonus it's a small footprint on end with the 112 on top, nice mini stack. Granted we were playing some classic Blues and rock. Even with the weight of the JBL the cab is so small and light I would guess around 35-40 lbs. I could have put 3 of em' in the trunk of a Camrey.
    Now it will never replace my 4 Berg. cabs or Aggies but ...maybe the Aggies, but options are always great! Plus I'm moving out all my big heavy cabs.
    I'm just putting this out as a "possible option. The modeling program he used said the cab was about a half foot bigger than needed and the port was just about right.
    The reason I'm writing this is that I know there lots of these floating around, I don't know if a lot of them are 4Ohms. But if I had read the threads before I probably wouldn't have tried it at all, just saying don't believe everything you read. As always ymmv etc. be well all and merry happy etc.
     
    slade likes this.
  2. jnewmark

    jnewmark Just wanna play the groove. Supporting Member

    Aug 31, 2006
    NW Ohio
    Third St. Cigar Records staff musician.
    I have dropped JBL K140's, and E140's in all sorts of cabs that did not come stock with either of them. Most times I liked the JBL speaker more than the stock. I even put a K140 in my Roland DB700, and it sounds great, although heavier ! Now, I don't play real loud gigs that much, and , when I do, I have PA support. Most of the tech guys here will tell you it's at best, a crapshoot. But I must be rolling 7's because it's been pretty much an improvement over whatever was in those cabs to begin with.
     
    slade likes this.
  3. Yea I was frankly stunned how it blew the Neo away. Remember the JBLi is 4 Ohms and the stock was 8. Don't get me wrong in that I dig my Neo AE212 and Neo112 and I don't like heavy stuff anymore, of course the Bergs kill and I realize some folks don't dig Neos but whatever works for "you" right! Besides I've got more than my fair share of Ceramics as well. It's just That at 62 plus, anything that makes the schlep easier makes me happy and this little Schroeder is so small to begin with the extra weight is neglible and it's hardly any bigger than the Aggie 112.
     
  4. BassmanPaul

    BassmanPaul Inactive

    I took a look but couldn't find a 2225I just a J 16Ω and an H 8Ω. I bought three trashed 2205 chassis' and had 2225 cone kits installed into them. One was Ceramic and the other two AlNiCo.

    In the early Eighties a built a cabinet that I designed to suit a JBL K140 for a friend. He returned it to me sans woofer. Needing a system to leave at our rehearsal place I dropped the Ceramic unit into the cabinet. Its performance in that service blew me away.

    In my mind it is a really good driver.
     
  5. agedhorse

    agedhorse Supporting Member Commercial User

    Feb 12, 2006
    Davis, CA (USA)
    Development Engineer-Mesa Boogie, Development Engineer-Genzler (pedals), Product Support-Genz Benz
    The 2225 is one of my favorite drivers, works well with a nice round low end. I have also designed a few very nice mixed driver size cabinets (yes, horror of horrors, I know ;) ) specifically taking advantage of the electro-acoustic performance of this driver. I have also done the same thing using a 2240 or 41 on the bottom.

    Another combination that works well is a 2225 on the bottom and a 2220 on the top (not sharing the same acosutic space) with appropriate tunings, not unlike a D140/D130 combination.
     
    slade likes this.
  6. jnewmark

    jnewmark Just wanna play the groove. Supporting Member

    Aug 31, 2006
    NW Ohio
    Third St. Cigar Records staff musician.
    Just curious, why do you guys like the 2225 for bass, over the JBL drivers specifically designed for bass guitar , like the K and E series ?
     
  7. BassmanPaul

    BassmanPaul Inactive

    In my case I had an empty cabinet and a spare driver. Having a need I put them together. I was very pleasantly surprised at the result. I won't change from my Acmes for gigs but the combination works well.
     
  8. Hey jnewmark If you reread my post you'll see that my bud had the spkr laying around and I had the cab so it was a well considered and briefly researched project and he did model it on the computer and the numbers lined up pretty well. The experiment was in my opinion (YMMV) a success! And hey if Agedhorse says he likes them, 2225 4Ohm that is, well...who am I to argue with him lol! As always to each his own. And I have about 10 different cabs to choose from so this was just a fun quicki experiment that worked well we both thought, and my friend has modeled and built a lot of cabs for MI applications.
     
  9. And to paraphrase Bassman Paul, I won't be giving up my Bergs anytime soon haha.

    PS; thanks Agedhorse for the best amp I've ever owned and that includes a Glock!
     
    slade likes this.
  10. agedhorse

    agedhorse Supporting Member Commercial User

    Feb 12, 2006
    Davis, CA (USA)
    Development Engineer-Mesa Boogie, Development Engineer-Genzler (pedals), Product Support-Genz Benz
    Thanks man!

    The HF rolloff of the 2225 makes it a fairly dark speaker, but alone with an amp that has a naturally bright voicing it can smooth things out, and with a suitable top cabinet that has reasonably similar phase response to the bottom 2225 cabinet, it can deliver some tones that just are not possible with either alone (IF that's your sound).

    I spend many years working with JBL speakers, went to the warranty/recone school in 1978 and developed an appreciation for some of their very targeted approaches. I also serviced a bunch of JBL products while doing my time in the cinema service industry and when speakers can survive being operated 10-12 hours/day for 20 years, there's some value there that just can't be matched by "race to the bottom" oriented companies. The cinema chain that I serviced for had about 10,000 JBL drivers in their theatre inventory, along with maybe 4-5000 QSC power amps which I also serviced.
     
    slade likes this.
  11. slade

    slade

    Apr 5, 2001
    man, that's a cool perspective.
     
  12. jnewmark

    jnewmark Just wanna play the groove. Supporting Member

    Aug 31, 2006
    NW Ohio
    Third St. Cigar Records staff musician.
    That's what I was thinking about the 2225, that it was a darker sounding driver, than say, the K140, which, imho, has a vey sweet sounding top end. I rarely felt the need to have a " brighter " top end when using one or more K140's, thus I would never think about using the 2225 as a stand alone driver in a 115 cab. But, if that's what ya like, then that's all that matters. :)
     
  13. agedhorse

    agedhorse Supporting Member Commercial User

    Feb 12, 2006
    Davis, CA (USA)
    Development Engineer-Mesa Boogie, Development Engineer-Genzler (pedals), Product Support-Genz Benz
    There are players that like a darker tone, and if you get a 2225 up closer to your ears, the mids may be appropriate for some players.
     
  14. I've used E 140's in a 80's Sunn B215 cab and loved the tone. It had enough low end - easily. The tone was very very nice. I don't have that cab any longer but now I have an original K140 that deserves a cab build someday. Long live JBL man.