Hi all. Ive read some previous threads on the topic; but hoping a poll and some personal stories might help me out in making a decision. Ive been playing a peavey jazz neck for a year. Before that, ive played yamaha and ibanez, all thin necks (1.5 nuts). i got a squier P about 2 weeks ago. I know its new, but struggling with the neck. Mostly its the hand cramps & fatigue; and an overall feeling that its not natural. But i LOVE the sound so want to push through . I also bought a no name, MIJ, "fender specs" e Bay jazz neck. But it didnt fit, not even close. So i Sent it back. Heres where im at: P neck thoughts... i find for short periods its not THAT different . I like the idea of keeping bass stock, not fussing and over- customizing. Keep it simple. And pushing myself to improve technique and flexibility. Ive played a bit of upright bass too, so why is this so uncomfortable? J neck thoughts... this has long been my idea of my "dream" bass. P p-up, J neck. My muscle memory leans this way. I value endurance for long gigs, so want a bass that i feel comfy with for those. Budget has ruled out me searching for a different bass, so these are my 2 options at the moment. Id love to hear your thoughts. Thanks for stopping by!