My first bass was a nasty Squier P copy. Since I haven't been playing it lately, but I'll never sell it, I decided to fix it up a bit. The Warmoth J neck is amazing. No dead spots as far as i can tell, and it only needed minimal truss rod adjustments. I routed for and popped in some SD hots, and they don't really nail either the P or the J tone perfectly, I have yet to find a PJ set that does. They're so much beefier, they even make my Behringer 30 sound good. I can't wait to test it out with my real amp at practice. The pickup cover doesn't really take the look anywhere near "vintage" IMO, but it makes an comfy thumb rest, and it looks awesome too.