Question about pickup splitting (Split P + Single jazz + standard Humbucker in one!)

Discussion in 'Pickups & Electronics [BG]' started by Bassitudes, Dec 17, 2014.

  1. delano

    25.0%
  2. nordstrand

    50.0%
  3. seymour duncan

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  4. fralin

    8.3%
  5. custom/other

    25.0%
Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    edit: see later posts. type of humbucker has been found, now what remains is the which and how, as well as additional questions

    tldnr: (need a humbucker that can be split to a p-shaped humbucking single, a jazz shaped single and a full double row buck. what is it, where can i get it, how do i wire it? do i need a unit to make a mishmash of pickups and preamp work together? if so what is it and where can i get it?)


    K, so i want to create a WORKHORSE bass guitar. It has to cover the tones I need all in one (by using push pull or mini toggles to swap pickup config selection.). I'm having trouble finding a certain pickup, was wondering if you guys knew which fits the bill or how to turn one that i can get into the one that i need.

    the required tones are:

    (if looking at it straight on to see the exposed polepieces, with possible dummy coils farthest away from you, aka underneath the unit)

    -the top left and bottom right area of the bucker for a p-bass sound as, say, setting #1 (preferably also top right and bottom left for the other split-p pickup sound as setting #1.5. I refuse to use a straight line pbass pickup for the p-sound, the split P is what i'm looking for)

    -then also the top left and bottom left for a single jazz sound as setting #2 (preferably also both rights for a slightly different single jazz sound as setting #2.5)

    -all 4 coils for a sounds like the neck-side pickup on a 2H stingray as setting #3 (for example, i know about the way rays only sound like rays with MM preamp or comparable unit)

    is this possible? am i thinking of a pipe dream?

    what does a humbucker need to be to be switchable in this way? (how many coil, how many wire, etc)

    any ideas on an exact humbucker that can do both the "split-p" sound when split diagonally and the "jazz pickup" sound when split into single coil? this to me is the most important. it's ok if it can't do both sides interchangeably, what's important is that it gets both major sounds in at least one way.

    The brand doesn't matter as long as it can feasibly work alongside a delano "the hybrid 5" in the bridge zone, as that's what's going in the bass no matter what. i heard something about a bartolini unit that allows adjustment of resistance to help match pickups to preamps or pickups to each other, or something like that. is this what i need to make two vastly different pickups work well in an active setting with each other?

    thanks for you help, and sorry about the length. I can create some rough pictures to demo what i mean by which pickups are selected if anyone needs clarification.
     
    Last edited: Dec 17, 2014
  2. BlueTalon

    BlueTalon Happy Cynic Supporting Member

    Mar 20, 2011
    Inland Northwest
    Endorsing Artist: Turnstyle Switch
    I think Delano is as close as you are going to get.

    MC4HY.jpg
     
    SirMjac28 and Bassitudes like this.
  3. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    that's a pic of the same hybrid pickup i already plan to use in the bridge position. the problem is it goes MM to Jazz. i'm looking for Split-P to jazz, preferably with MM as well, but not required
     
  4. BlueTalon

    BlueTalon Happy Cynic Supporting Member

    Mar 20, 2011
    Inland Northwest
    Endorsing Artist: Turnstyle Switch
    Something like this might work, if it's comprised of two split-coil J pickups. But I think you are going to have to have that one custom made.

    IMG_0686-354x181.jpg
     
  5. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    in theory, wouldn't you only need something with 4 coils (basically 2 sets of split p coils all side by side), one for each set of 2 polepieces (in terms of a four string bucker with 8 total polepieces) grouped together, with a wire out from each coil? i could have sworn i saw this type before somewhere but i can't remember who makes it.
     
  6. BlueTalon

    BlueTalon Happy Cynic Supporting Member

    Mar 20, 2011
    Inland Northwest
    Endorsing Artist: Turnstyle Switch
    There are lots of different split-coil J pickups out there.

    13884a63-10d3-49a4-b2bd-367356e066a5_zpsa5cae32e.jpg

    But I don't know of any pickup like in my previous post that has four such coils.
     
    MaxJJK and Bassitudes like this.
  7. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    ah, in that case you might be right in that you could use a double split coil J set and then just run the leads to a switcher to make the specific combos you want. i don't really need it to be in one casing. although...

    if this is the case, when a pickup is labelled as a quad coil ( like the Delano MC 5 HE , for example) it is indeed that each pickup has 4 of those mini coils in it, isn't it? since a 2 coil would be 2 that run the entire length of the strings side by side, 4 would be each of those cut in half, likely for self-humcancelling J style settings. if this is the case (i have no idea what the inside of a pickup looks like, i always thought quads just ran 2 dummy coils for cancelling underneath the regular ones) then the trick would be simply to run the necessary amount of wire out from each mini coil, wouldn't it? Either that or get a pickup that already includes the wires.

    at least i think so, i'm a complete noob at understanding the way pickup switching works.
     
  8. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    "To give a visual example:

    MMbucker.png

    Suppose the coils are named N(ea), N(dg), B(ea) and B(dg) (I think tubby.twins named them as such on the PDF above, too). Suppose the coils are wound and magnetically polarized like this:

    N(ea), B(ea): clockwise, N-up
    N(dg), B(dg): counter-clockwise, S-up.

    Thus the combinations are as follows:

    N-jazz: N(ea)+N(dg)
    prec: N(ea)+B(dg)
    MM: N(ea)N(dg) + B(ea)B(dg)
    R-prec: B(ea)+N(dg)
    B-jazz: B(ea)+B(dg)

    So if you look at the upper table, all combinations are RW-RP. No phase issues, as far as I can tell." posted by Stealth,Oct 22, 2010


    This is EXACTLY what I'm looking for. So it is possible. Now the updated question is which pickups exist that come made like this already/how hard is it to do to a quad coil pickup? And out of the ones that do exist which ones actually sound like an actual P and J bass in passive mode?

    Can you set up the pickup to use a functional series+parallel+out of phase 3 way selector toggle/switch/knob in addition to this wiring scheme outlined above? That is part of a future plan.
     
    PortlandBass77 likes this.
  9. mmbongo

    mmbongo I have too many basses. Supporting Member

    Yeah you need a quad coil MM pickup so you can do split p, reverse split p, jazz front, jazz rear. Lots of options.
     
    Bassitudes likes this.
  10. LUpton

    LUpton

    Oct 22, 2012
    Tampa, FL
    Probably too old for this sh--
    I've had ideas similar to this, also, and I would probably choose the Nordstrand MM 4.4 or 5.4, or the Delano equivalent, but then, where do you locate this pickup for optimum usage?

    In the P sweet spot, the P switching combos would probably be real good, but MM and J tones could suffer. In the MM sweet spot, the humbucker would sound right, but the P & J tones could suffer, and if the pup was located nearer the bridge, the rear coils could get a J bridge sound, but the P & MM sounds could suffer. Rock and a hard place...

    I would probably put this in the MM sweet spot, and deal with the other compromises, but I'm a big Ray sound fan. YMMV, and good luck with your choices. Not sure you're going to find a 'holy grail' pickup that will do everything you want. If this was possible, it would probably have been invented and marketed by now...
     
  11. JustForSport

    JustForSport Guest

    Nov 17, 2011
    Delano and Bartolini both make quad-coil pickups that can be wired this way.
    As noted above, placement is another thing...
     
  12. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    i'm using at least 2 pickups and an MM/ jazz is going in the bridge. As for the p sweet spot i'm probably going to put it so in the traditional P config it's in the same spot. that's the same spot for a jazz, leaving two "tighter" versions of the pickups selectable, which is fine by me, especially since the bass already has a mudbucker going up at the fretboard
     
  13. LUpton

    LUpton

    Oct 22, 2012
    Tampa, FL
    Probably too old for this sh--
    Sorry, for some reason I thought this was going to be a single pickup config.

    Sounds like you've got it covered - good luck!
     
    Bassitudes likes this.
  14. I hate to tell you this but if you take a hard look at a split-coil P you'll discover the reason they're staggered the way they are. You're not getting that tone any other way. Four coils in a neat little box won't do it.
     
    Bassitudes likes this.
  15. RichSnyder

    RichSnyder Columbia, MD Supporting Member

    Jun 19, 2003
    I've thought about something like this, trying to get a P/J/MM in one bass. I think that in the end something is going to suffer tonally. You'll maybe get one great sound and the others suffer. So I've settled with a bass that has a P and an MM pickup, both sound great and a J that sounds great. Two basses and it covers anything.

    Have you seen the SIMS Super Quad pickups?

    http://www.enfieldguitars.com/
     
    tubby.twins and Bassitudes like this.
  16. BlueTalon

    BlueTalon Happy Cynic Supporting Member

    Mar 20, 2011
    Inland Northwest
    Endorsing Artist: Turnstyle Switch
  17. Bassitudes

    Bassitudes Guest

    Dec 16, 2014
    Toronto, Ontario
    fb2100wa1bk_back.jpg
    if you look closely at the pickup from underneath, the coils do not seem to extend into the area covered by each other, only the plastic and magnet does. I'm sure it will sound very close.
     
  18. That's not the issue. It's the shape and size of the wide, squat coils. The halves are offset because they won't fit otherwise. Making the coils taller and narrower makes them fit, but it won't sound like a split P (but maybe close to a single coil P) . Been there done that, with a Bart quad coil.
     
  19. The Doctor

    The Doctor Guest

    Jun 27, 2003
    Peterborough, UK
    Hi guys! I'm a pro bassist from England and have been using an Enfield Lionheart bass since March this year, these basses feature (as has been mentioned already!) the SimS Super Quad pickups, which give true single coil, split and humbucking settings in one single p/up housing! Having two pickups gives me over 15 different coil settings, each pickup housing has a tri-color LED such that you can see exactly which coils are in use, red LED = split coil, green = single coil and blue = humbucker! I have 84 basses and this Enfield has taken over as my main bass. Enfield also sell the pickups as retrofit items and can also send out a proper installation jig system, I would check these out as they do the business!
     
  20. RichSnyder

    RichSnyder Columbia, MD Supporting Member

    Jun 19, 2003
    Does it have passive or active electronics?