Roger Waters Dark Side of the Moon tour

I was lucky enough to catch his show here in Bogotá. It was really good, the best concert I have ever been to...and I had just been to a Jamiroquai show a couple o weeks earlier.

As you said, the stage effects were just amazing as where the perfomances. I was particualrly impress by Roger Waters' ability to sing and play bass at the same time, specially during Have a Cigar where he played some really nice lines.

BTW the guy who played bass when Roger picked up a guitar (Andy fairweather I think is his name) really impressed me. I enjoyed hearing the differences between a fiunegrstyle bass and a picked bass. Roger was so much easier to hear but Andy's lines where deeper and just sitted better in the groove IMO.

 

i saw him a month ago, great show.

 

That's Andy Fairweather-Lowe, formerly of Amen Corner.

Isn't Mr Waters still lip synching a lot of the vocals (particularly Have a Cigar)?

There was certainly ample YouTube evidence that he was earlier in the tour and this was the subject of earlier threads.

 

i was at his show last year in the bay area. AMAZING!

 

I will be seeing the tour June 1 in Philly. Can't wait!

 

I believe so. Great show. Great lip-synching.

 

Yes indeed

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DeYuvlUd-cY

Sad to see/hear at this stage of his career IMHO.

 

I think that was just a bad night. I think every singer has had at least one. In Bogotá he was in fine voice, check it out:

 

Check out his DVD, "In the Flesh." Live in Portland, Oregon; great show. Your money's worth for that one.

 

Greetings

I love PF but can Waters actually play???

Gilmore played a lot of the bass parts on the albums and has been quoted saying Waters is awful.

The band was great Waters can't sing a lick either can I except I don't front!

 

That was a lot better

 

So, you contend that he was lip-syncing in that clip??

 

Roger waters can play yes, not spectacular in anyway, and he sings great on fletcher memorial.

But u see, roger waters skills are not exactly the practical, he's a musical genious and wrote most of pink floyds greatest material.. syd barret was the true genious though..

David Gilmour cant write an album unless he's surrounded by proffesional composers from all around the world to help him, he's a good player but without people like waters writing music for him then he's nobody.

 

Lilterier:

Couldn't have put it better myself. Gilmour's lastest solo effort proves that admirably IMHO.

Thangfish:

I don't "contend" anything. You can call it "mountaineering" if you like. All I know is that, if I had shelled out my hard earned dosh for a ticket and I was presented with the tosh which is in evidence on that clip, I would be mightily unimpressed.

My opinion and my prerogative I think?

 

I think both guys can be called awesome muscicians without being controvertial, one can play incredible stuff, the other one can do awesome compositional work... I mean, they are actually great artists (yeah... ART... lol), but... It was very funny when they got togethes for the live8 concert... I expected too much maybe, but I prefeer them the way the are now.

 

Bad Voice...Bad Playing...Lip Synching...

WHO CARES!!!!....

It's ICON Roger Waters doing what he does best...old Pink Floyd...just sit back and enjoy him while he's still doing it.

 

Wow...still debating the Waters/Gilmour/Barret/PF argument?

A) you can't judge anything from Youtube.

B) if Roger WAS lip-synching, I'd at least cut him some slack for it. He's getting up there in years and lets face it, his vocal chords aren't what they used to be. I'd commend him on trying to preserve the quality of the performance instead of coughing in the mic a lot and going flat or sharp the whole night.

C) I would say that judging from Floyd's success AFTER Syd Barret died, that Syd wasn't as creative as we'd like to think he was. Who knows though? He died way before we could find out for sure.

D) IMO, I think when Waters and Gilmour collaborate together, great things always happen. You can tell from Waters' solo efforts and from Pink Floyd in the post-Waters era. Neither have obtained the level of success they enjoyed when they were together.

 

Considering the state of Roger's voice in recent years, I think he has every right to lip synch if he has to. His voice is obviously too trashed for regular use, it's not like he's being lazy about it.

 

If you go to one of these shows, pay close attention to the backup singers. One of them will be P.P Arnold, the former "Ikette". Keith Emerson's early band, The Nice, was her backing group. Good to see she's still performing!

Slug