I plan on replacing the current pickups in my Essex Fretless P bass in about 2 months. I am debating between Seymour Duncan pickups and Bartolinis. Im in a band that plays funk/classical rock. Which pickups do you think will give me a better tone for a fretless? I still want the bass to be relatively punchy and smooth sounding, not too rough and growly.
If you're open to another suggestion, I'd highly recommend a Nordstrand P. I'm not sure you'd be happy with the tone of the Bart, and it sounds like the Nordie would be perfect for the tone you're looking for. They're wound with Formvar wire and use Alnico 5 magnets. I think it would be perfect for your situation.
The Barts will be warm and smooth, but not very punchy. The Duncans are punchy and growly. The ones I'd suggest to you are Bill Lawrence. They are less pricey than the Nordstrand pickups and I'd bet they will get you the tone you are looking for. I had them in a fretless jazz and just loved them. The Bill Lawrence website is here: http://www.billlawrence.com/index.html BTW, I have no connection to Bill Lawrence. I've just used his pickups and loved them. JPJ, It is cool that you like the Nordstrand pickups, but I think it might be nice to inform everyone that you recommend them to that you are a dealer.
Xyllion, Actually, I do, but I prefer to do that via PM. As a player, I have general opinions that someone might find helpful...just like anyone else at TB. But when it comes to detailed discussions with individuals, I like to keep that off the forum, if you know what I mean. And for the record, I agree....Bill Lawrence makes great pickups too!
Ive never heard a p bass with EMG's... how would they be for my situation? It sounds right now that Seymour Duncans would be my best bet, but yea, how bout EMGs? Just wondering.
I recommend a Fender 62 Reissue pickup. Classic tone for a decent price. Great for the style of music you describe.
