But hold your horses. I am only talking about the pickup. And in reverse. As I mentioned in another thread, I got a charvel PJ bass. This P position sounds the best to my ears. The E on the seventh fret of the A string and the E on the second fret of the D string sound different tonally but they are very balanced. The G string is still twangy but it's way bassier than it is on my jazz (comparably to the neck pickup). Also, the E and A strings don't have that "wonk" tone P basses are associated with, they purr with more clarity because their coil is closer to the bridge. So I guess I shouldn't stray away from P pickups... I just need to have them reversed and I am good to go!