Which would you recommend between these two (they're pretty similarly priced) for a punk-jazz-thrash-funk-alternative-metal band? It needs to cut through very heavy drums and a loud crunchy guitar. My rig is a Peavey Firebass -> 1820 enclosure, and I use a Behringer Composer Pro compressor.
I'm sure about the yamaha- I don't think I ahve played that model, however, the Spector will cut through quite well. I owned a Q5 for awhile and it was a great bass with strong clear and growly tone. Heavy lows and clean and clear highs. I highly recommend it.
Hmmm...uhh...the maple top on the Spector would make it sound quite bright, right? (I'm a wood ignoramus )
Spector, not just compared to a Yahama, I own a ReBop 5 Czech and love it, I would take a Spector over almost anything but that's just me.
Get the spector, you can't ever go wrong with a Spector, and yes, it's MUCH brighter than the yamaha, but more because of the pre amp and pick ups than the maple top.
Get the Spector. Not sure how much brightness a maple top adds - remember it might only be 1/8" think! Never had a bolt on Spector (although I almost won one of these in an ebay auction) but the 2 I still have are the best quality basses I've ever had (NS5CR and a REX2000/5 - Korean build quality is fantastic) Don't know much about the Yamaha - although I imagine the build quality on that will be good (I have a Yammy Attitude - another good bass). But enough listening to us - go try them and see what you feel plays,feels and sounds better!
Dont know either bass but if you go yamaha, Musicians friend is blowing out a BB1500 (maybe 1600 can't remember excact model) and a nice TRB bass way below their usual price.