I've played all but the EB and the Labella... Pro Steels hands down best for me with the Smiths a close second. Rotos were my mainstay for a long while but the late 80s-early 90s run where every 3rd set WOULDN'T be dead kinda turned me away. The GHS are mostly horrid, I used them for 2 years but only because my guitarist had a deal and I was getting them for about $7 for a 5 string set IMO/E
My faves are R. Cocco strings. They sound great and are truly one of the most playable strings out there. I've tried all brands and nothing comes close. My second choice would be D'adarrio Prisms. Ken Smiths, they don't last for me, which is unusual for steel. It would be nice if these guys could label the quality of steel they were using, then at least you could know you're paying for it.
The new D'addario Pro Steels are giving me good results, although I'm still adjusting to their firmer feel and more aggresive tonality. I have yet to run across a quality control type issue, so no "dead duds" yet... You just never know... I may very well not be able to adjust and end up going back to my long time faves, the Dean Markley SR2000 Will Lees. Now there's a damn good SS string set!
which do you think are better? are the PROSTEELS harsd?? is the low end nice and tight and the high end smooth?
From what I've been able to ascertain, the ProSteels have a more aggresive midrange, which is great in that it helps the bass stand out in the mix. The highs are what I'd call "all there", and the bass is BIG... all in all it's a wonderful sound. It's the tension... the feel... of the set that I find myself having to "get used to". It is a "tighter", "firmer" feeling set, so in my case, I'm having to adjust some of my attack technique. Naturally this also necessitates some physical adjustments to the bass itself... you know, truss rod tweaks, action adjustments, etc. Given time I may find that I like the ProSteels more... but right now, the standard I still find myself referring to is the one set in my mind by the Will Lees.
Does it chew up your fingers? On the last set of stainless strings I used (a long time ago) my fingers dragged when I plucked, because the strings were so rough. But these strings intrigue me, with the whole 'mid presence' thing, as I like a lot of mids for that gritty tone. Thanks, Graeme
Yeah, I think those were the ones. 'Swing Bass' if I'm not mistaken. After playing those, I switched to nickel, but I've been meaning to try steels again. Graeme
These strings have that Roto-ish texture, but I haven't noticed that "Roto-Rash" you're talking about. As a matter of fact, I haven't suffered that "Roto-rash" with any other strings but Rotos... and since I haven't used them in over 20 years... heh... well, 'nuff said! As for overtones off of the SR2000's well, yeah I guess they are more "alive" than other strings, but I find that I like that quality more often than not, and besides... I would think it's easier to EQ out certain overtones if you find them annoying than it would be to EQ in a "brighter, livlier" tone. You take the "good" with the "bad" so to speak.
I voted for the DR Lo-Riders which are an awesome string. I also happen to like Dean Markley Blue Steels. They are quite comfortable to play as well. Plus they last a long time and have a good tone (IMO) that cuts really well through the mix.
I hate teh Blue Steels, Love teh LoRiders- they are perfect and I love them. That first week ro two on the LoRiders caqn be rough when they have that new ring.
My personal favorite ain't even on your list and it's certainly a consideration! LaBella Hard Rockin' Steel - For $18.50 per set thanks to bpstrings.com, I can get these strings that go on, settle in quickly and have a nice lifetime of about four months heavilly played. They've got the treble you look for in a stainless string and still have that nice deep fundamental, overall great response and wonderful customer service to boot. Then I'll follow up in order with: D'Addario Prosteels Rotosound RS66
i just got a set that was tapered...a little too short on the E for a Long Scale set - the taper rests in the nut, throwing off the string height- otherwise Great strings.
I used to play DR loriders for a while but they were really expensive. Although they did last me a long time. Now I've switched to Labella super steps. I love them.