Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Miscellaneous [BG]' started by Davidoc, Jul 21, 2001.
What's your pick?
What's the difference?
I've had the nut that holds a Schaller on the strap back off and drop a bass. Never again. The Dunlop is held on by a C-clip which cannot come off the button on the strap. Only thing I've seen negative about the Dunlop is that the mechanism can get gummed up a bit and sticky, just put a little 3-in-1 oil on it and move the mechanism a few times, all better. I generally never remove my strap from the bass, so this isn't an issue anyhow.
I use the Dunlop also, never had any problem in all those years.
thanks for the input;
-13 votes for dunlp?!
I've had both, The Dunlops never failed me, the Schallers slipped twice.
i love my dunlops...... theyve never let me down so i havent tried others. i used to use tape
also, Dunlop locks come standard on some basses like warwicks. i don't think anything comes with schallers.
Actually DHC, Fenders (at least some of them) and Spectors come with the Schallers as OEM straplocks. You'd think Stuart would use something a bit more reliable...
Schaller... that's the only ones they sell 'round these parts
I didn't vote because I use both with equal success. I had started using Dunlops 'cause I heard bad things about Schallers. Then my custom order bass came standard with Schallers. Haven't had a problem with any slips on any of 'em.
I used to use Dunlops till I got my warwick. The dunlops kept popping off causing me to drop my bass. I went throught 3 sets before I decided to make the change to schallers. As far as the nut on the Schaler straplocks coming loose, a drop of glue or fingernail polish or locktight will cure that.
I've had Schallers on my bass for six months and have had no problems at all. No loose nuts or slips or anything. Maybe the folks who dropped their basses play way more aggressive and jump around a lot. If that was the case then I'd use plumber's tape. The white stuff that you are supposed to wrap around the thread on PVC pipes to seal them. I used that on my snowboard and the screws never loosen. That board has been through a lot worse than my bass so I'm pretty sure that plumber's tape could fix the problem of loose nuts completely.
Where's the 'other' catagory? I have been using Fender straplocks for several months now. The only problem I encountered, was that the nut that holds the lock to the strap came loose. I fixed that problem by putting some clear fingernail polish on the threads, tightening the nuts back down and then putting a dab of nail polish in the little groove where the nut actually meets the threads. My only complaint is that with the strap on the bass, the pin and lock combo is too long to fit in my case, so I have to remove the strap each time I put it away.
I got dunlops today.
After much agrivation, some cuts on my finger and some needle-nose plyers, I managed to get the locking clips in place. What should I do if I wanna change straps? I really don't wanna take off that locking clip.
I bought a set of Schallers and got home to find that the screws were too small. I either have to get a different set or fill the holes on my bass body and start fresh (if I wanna use the ones I have).
Oh well, being a lazy S.O.B., I think I know which route I'll take.
I've been using Schallers for probably 13-14 years and have never had one fail. I've never tried Dunlops so I can't comment on those.
I've been using Schallers for about 6 months now and they work great. They are pretty heavy duty and I haven't had one fall off. They are also easy to take on and off.
For those who want to change straps, I did see that the Dunlop site shows that they package sets of just the strap pins. But I have yet to see a store that stocks these!
Hey, here's a hint i picked up, and should be helpful if the strap button screw is too small for the hole in your bass. Stick a toothpick in the hole on your bass and pour in a little elmers glue, then screw in the strap button... this does wonders for stopping the button from coming lose. The guys in my band play les pauls, which, i think, are heavier than most basses, and after both of their buttons came loose, this kept them from coming loose again. This works for normal straps too, but if you don't have straplocks, then you shouldn't play standing up anyway... not if you love your bass