I might be crazy, but I'm considering selling/trading my beloved JO5 for a JO4 or some other 4 string. PROS: I like having the versatility to be able to play in different positions with the root on the B string. I hardly do this when just playing on my own but sometimes do when playing in a band setting or jamming. CONS: I just play better, more comfortably, and more creatively on a 4 string. (although this "improvement" in my playing isn't extremely significant) And a smaller profile neck is more comfortable to me. I like not having to always worry about muting the B string. I know it seems like the list of cons outweighs pros, but there is also the factor of having to go through the trouble of selling/trading/buying, and the fact that despite the cons of the 5, I do really like this bass. So, those of you that have gone from 5 to 4, any regrets? Oh and here's a pic, cause without it the bass in question doesn't exist, right? {} Thanks for any opinions, before I jump into anything.. PS: For Lakland lovers out there, are there any other brands of bass I should consider that are similar to Lakland in feel, quality, sound in the skyline price range? Or should I stick with what I know?
well you said it yourself man "I just play better, more comfortably, and more creatively on a 4 string. And a smaller profile neck is more comfortable to me. I like not having to always worry about muting the B string." with the limited amount you say you use the B, why is it needed? for the odd time you use it, seems like a waste to me considering all the pluses you have for 4 string. wish I could help on lakland quality, but no experience with them. but i will say that out of all the basses I've played musicmans always have a high quality and amazing feel
I edited my OP to answer your post a bit, I'm also just thinking "Is it really worth it to go through the hassle of buying and selling just to have the same bass with one less string?" I'm curious to hear from anyone who has done something like this in the past and how their decision turned out
That's a good suggestion, but another side to the story is I do have 2 other 4 strings. For quite a while all I really played were 5 strings and now that I bought a 4 I realized I may not need the 5. Problem is, I like Laklands, and I need some cash. So my tentative plan was to just downsize to one Lakland 4 string and sell off one of my other basses as well. PM'd you
easy then, if you really like the 5, sell the other 2 4 strings and buy that really good Lakland 4 string
good idea! I was going to suggest buying a 4 string Lakie to accompany your JO5....MF has some GREAT deals on a few select models here: http://www.musiciansfriend.com/navigation?q=lakland you have to clickaround to find the deals (as only SOME are really low! not sure why...) PS - not really "advertising" for MF.....just happened to see this in another thread.... To me - NOTHING feels as good as a Lakie....
Replace it with a 4string. Your own comments make this highly sensible imo. Ive owned a 3 fivers, no regrets on not owning any for the past several yrs.
Plus the "play better/more creatively on a 4" thing is probably all mental. You just need to fully convince yourself that there is nothing you can do on a JO4 that you can't do on your JO5.
Here are some related products that TB members are talking about. Clicking on a product will take you to TB’s partner, Primary, where you can find links to TB discussions about these products. Browser not compatible