I have an Artec mudbucker in a couple of basses and really like what it adds...especially on a J bass. The P with a far neck mudbucker or Model One is more traditional, but I think it works better on a bass with a bridge pickup like a J or a Stingray or a G&L. I think the structural thing is nothing to worry about if you are careful. I have heard of it being done to a Ric and those are really thin bodies. Fyi, I have mine wired with a 3 way switch with the neck/middle J pickup. Works nice since I usually solo the middle or use the bridge with the far neck (and the middle off). Let us know how it turns out!