I have a 2012 Fender Precision 5 that I really like. I am considering modifying it to be a sort of 5 string version of a Tony Franklin fretted. This means installing a pickup in the bridge position and adding a three-way toggle to select neck, bridge, or neck+bridge in parallel. The main issue is getting a jazz-type pickup that balances well with the P pickup. I talked to Nordstrand about this. They recommend thier P pickup plus thier big split. From what I could find on youtube, the Nordstrand P pickup has more range than the Fender and is smoother in the mids. To me the Fender pickup is a little shy in the deep lows and extended highs, and has a distinct low-mid puch and hi-mid gank. Not smooth at all, but a great classic Fender sound. I am not against replacing the P pickup, but I may not like the Nordstrand as well. I use this bass for modern rock, so I am pretty happy with the sound. If I don't change the P pickup, what jazz-type pickup would you recommend? Do you think I can get the same punch and bite out of the Nordstrand P as the stock with some eq?