I have an Eden WT550 amp and a couple of Avatar 112 cabs with a horn. I like a bright zingy Marcus type of tone for my 5 string Atelier Z Jazz. I get it by having the tweeter at 1/4 on the crossover and then boosting the treble on the Eden amp. I usually have the treble knob (4k ) at 2 o'clock and also boost 10K on the parametric about 5db. Today (it only took me 20 years) it dawned on me that I could also crank the horn all the way and then I wouldn't have to boost the highs on the amp as much. I haven't tried that kind of setting on a gig yet but in my room it sounds really good. I'm not sure which is better. I think the horn cranked and the amp treble back sounds a bit smoother. Have you guys experimented with that? What do you think?
Um... It's all about the Bass, 'bout the Bass, No Treble. Sorry. I couldn't resist. But seriously, If you think it's good, it is.
The zingy high end on the tweeter (usually everything above 4khz) is great for extra clarity, string noise, hand movement and static sounds from pedals. Tweeters (depending on the design) will sound very directional. You will hear lots of high end if you stand in front of your rig, but standing to the side results in less high end in the 4khz to 10khz range. In reality, I can see these frequencies being helpful in a solo situation where a lot of slap bass work or intimate playing is occurring. For your average blues/rock/metal show, the tweeter range of bass tones is just about useless. The extra clarity is going to to get swallowed up in the band mix faster than you can blink. For high end content, everything between 900hz and 4khz is a good range to add note definition. These frequencies typically come through the actual cone speakers and are usually easier to hear in a live situation. Lastly, if your technique is not the cleanest or quietest, the extra high end from the tweeter is going to make your inefficiencies much more noticeable.
Only you can decide what is best, but when I want sparkle, I open the x-over all the way, and use the EQ to cut as needed. As far as dispersion is concerned, it is moot as essentially ALL of your 4khz+ signal is coming from the horn. It is what it is, dispersion-wise, no matter what the x-over is set at, you can't improve it without elevating it, replacing it, or adding another one in a second cab, preferably with a reversed baffle. Avatar does reversed baffles, I think. Don't forget some nice fresh bright round wound hex-core stainless steel medium gauge strings! Ever try Sadowsky Black Label Stainless Steel or DR Low Riders? Also, if you do compression, try an EBS Multi-Comp in two-band mode. Is the Atelier Z Jazz OBP-3 equipped?
You are correct Jim. As far as dispersion of high end, everything below 4khz is at least coming through each woofer cone. You have MORE of a chance to fully hear it since every woofer cone is putting out those particular frequencies. Rather than just one small tweeter on a bass cab. That is my simplified version of explaining it.
My Atelier Z is the M265 model. I put a Sadowsky pre and Nordies in it. I use DR Hi Beams. It's a bright sounding Bass but it also has a lot of bottom. Marcus has always been my main mas as far as tone goes and this 5 string does it. And I do have a EBS multi comp, but I don't always use it. I have never really learned how to dial it in correctly. I've messed around with all kinds of settings including the internal trim pots. In the end I always like the uncompressed sound more. I do have two Avatar 112 cabs but usually one is enough for the venues I'm playing. And I always put the cab up on a milk crate.BTW what is a reversed baffle? You guys are answering some of my questions.(Thank you for that.) For example if I get more dispersion of highs when I dial back the crossover to let more of the above 4 k come through the woofer. To my ears the high end seems to sound sweeter when the tweeter is on full and the treble on the amp is back, but if that would make my highs disappear as I move away from the cab, then that's not good. I don't gig that much in the winter so I haven't tried it out on a job what it sounds like with the tweeter on full.But like I said in my room it sounds great. The first response from Scott Waldy (it's all about the bass and if you like it it's good) made me think I might have asked a stupid question here but I had a feeling there might be more to it than that. And sound dispersion certainly is an important factor because the places I play are usually not really big and I often don't go through the PA. Still, I like to have "my tone" not just in front of the cab but also throughout the room and on the sides of the stage too.
"Reversed baffle" means two cabs with mirror image faces (baffles) so that when one cab is inverted and put on top of the other cab, the hi-freq driver and/or mid-driver align vertically, as seen left and center in greenboy's fearful cab diagram below. See, http://greenboy.us/fEARful/modularity.htm
my problem has always been too much treble ... but maybe thats because i am using a 12" Audio Kinesis cab. that cab is hi-fi
Thanks for posting that. Is that going to make a big difference in clarity if those tweeters are next to each other?
So let me get this straight...some bass players are actually looking for more treble? Oh, don't get all panty-bunched...it's Christmas!!!
I can hear it. I have three 15/6/1 fEARful cabinets. One is inverted. In a simple informal test, the aligned mid/hi drivers were noticeably louder, on and off axis. I think you can find more from others' experiences on the greenboy forums. It is like when we stack cabs vertically instead of side-by-side. De facto line array effect? Since my current cabs can deliver highs and upper mids better than anything else I have ever had—my main rig just before going fEARful was an Epifani UL1 410 4 ohm, occasionally bolstered with a UL1 210 8 ohm cab—it is pretty moot in my case.
I played a Stingray 5 through and Eden WT-800 and one of their Eden D410T cabs (the one that looked like an SWR Goliath II) for a few years on the road and I always gave a slight boost in the same range on the sweepable highs. I only did a bit to bring out a little more of those "glassy" highs for slapping than just have an overall increase in volume in the highs. I ran the tweeter on the cab about 40% on and it worked out great.