Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Basses [BG]' started by parksung, Apr 21, 2009.
Is the J bass typically warmer than the P?
Not a realistic question. Warmth depends on strings, touch, specific pieces of wood, EQ, the amp, etc. It has almost nothing to do with the shape of the bass. I guess you could say that soloing the bridge pickup of a J is not usually a warm sound, but that's only one of the many J voices.
I'd say the P.
Definitely the P-Bass. Those wide, squat coils will always produce a fatter and midrangier sound than the Jazz's taller and narrower pickups. That's just physics, y'dig?
The others are right here though;flatwound strings and playing with your thumb (plucking, not slapping) or fingers (vs. a pick) will produce a warmer tone, even on a Jazz bass.
With the right technique and EQ and thermostat settings you'll probably sound pretty warm on either.
I don't know about warmer, but seems in the past many reggae players dug the J bass, favoring the neck pickup of course. Those cats know warm.
But personally I think Ps are cool and they can go plenty warm too.
My Jazz is warmer than ANY P-bass i have played... Whats a bit of a bugger really... as i want the more aggressive sound of the P.
Paradoxically , the P bass is a warmer sounding instrument but also more aggressive sounding
the P tends to sound richer in the low-medium mids, but the Jazz (with both pickups full on) tends to have more ultra-deep low end... so it depends what you mean by warmth: creamy low mids or filling beefy bass
Warm means different things to different people, but usually when people say warm they mean fat or richer in the lower freq's. In that case, it would have to be the P, bc of the pickups. The J pickups are more hi mid focused and the P's are more low mid focused. Don't forget you can get double stacked J pickups to get more lower freq's out of the J. Single coil J's can also be tuned differently to sound warm, so check with diff pickups from diff manufacturers. I would also lean twords an alder body w/ a rosewood neck over an ash body and maple neck.
My P is warm
They both sound great and both are very versatile for tones ranging from deep to grindy.
The J is a brighter (more treble) sounding bass with an inherent mid scoop (with both pickups on) yet in some ways the J is mellower sounding (to me).
The P has more of that certain un-scooped gutty punch.
Not really sure how you mean warm. If you roll some treble off the Jazz, it's pretty "warm". On the other hand, the P is kind of a ballsier sounding bass (more aggressive mids and lows).
I guess I'll say P.
With the right amp, any bass can sound warm.
Reggae cats also have crazy amp systems, which add to it!
And most importantly, it's mostly them that bring out the bottom!
Both the P and J can sound very warm but IMO it's a slightly different kind of warm with the J sounding more "blooming" and the P sounding a bit "thumpier" if that makes any sense.
The amp can be tweaked to get warmer tones with either but for me those two qualities still come through.
familyman rocked a very simple amp setup in almost every classic studio one upsetters/wailers recording to date.. he was all about technique and utilizing the sound of his actual instrument (less reliance on the amp, very low gain, near-flat settings).
albeit, i think his style has changed with the technology.. but those recordings don't lie
Flatwounds on a P
You'll almost never get a more thumpy, warm tone than you will with a P strung with nickel flats.
That's not to say that you can't get a warm tone out of a Jazz, though.
Have you ever tried tapewound strings?