Here's a clip of my Fender/Warmoth fretless P. I'm thinking about replacing the pickup and I would like some input. Clip I like the low end fullness of this sound, but the pickup seems to a add a metalic clanky quality that is not present in the acoustic sound of the bass. Is this typical of P pickups? I'm looking for something smoother and more natural sounding. Models I'm looking at are: Aero Bartolini 8S EMG Lindy Fralin Kent Armstrong Fender Original '62 maybe Seymour Duncan (which model?) Which of these do you think will give me the sound I'm looking for? I also have a piezo on this bass. It sounds like this. I like the smoothness of this sound but it is a little thin down low. Presently I don't have any way to blend the two pickups. For anyone interested, the bass is a '72 Fender Precision body with a Warmoth all rosewood fretless neck. The piezo is Graphtech. The bass is passive and I have a switch to select between the magnetic and piezo pickups. I recorded the samples through my Demeter VTBP-201s into my soundcard. Thanks in advance for your help.