For some time, I’ve wanted a second P bass, but after listening to videos and playing an example with flats, what I really want is a Jazz. If I move a couple of cabs in the near future, I will probably be on the hunt for a nice example. But as most of my attention has been on Precisions until recently, perhaps some of you can point me in the right direction. Here are a few parameters: - It doesn’t have to be a Fender, but Fenders are great. - It doesn’t have to be US-made but I’ll admit I’m a little snobbish about overseas stuff that isn’t MIJ. Lakland Skylines are an exception that comes to mind. I’m not looking to mod/replace stuff in order to upgrade. - Only 4-strings, and preferably 20-21 frets. - I will probably favor the neck pickup or blend in just a little from the bridge, so a great neck PU and placement is important to me. - The nut width of Jazz necks are nice, but I don’t like flat profiles. A nice round neck suits my hand better. The rounder the better. - I prefer the vintage 7.25” radius, but 9.5” is ok. - I don’t like string-thru only basses. I at least want the option to top-load strings. - Whatever I acquire will wear flats, probably Fender or La Bella. - I prefer passive to active, or at least the option to switch to passive. - I actually don’t like super-light basses so long as the neck doesn’t dive, and between 9-10 lbs seems to be my happy spot. - Up to $2k, but I’m not looking to spend all of that just because. Under $1k suits me just fine. A 70’s example under 10 lbs would be dreamy, but I don’t think I should shell out the clams right now. - I’m not much for signature basses. Perhaps a certain example fits all the criteria, but I wouldn’t normally search out a signature model as my first choice. - Pure bonus points: surf green would be kind of cool, but this is just non-essential fluff. This may not narrow things down much, but even so, your personal experience/preferences are appreciated. Jazz aficionados: educate me! Thanks in advance.
I just went the other way from Jazz type to P type for my main bass. I have a few Jazzs from Fender and Squier; but my number 1 is a PRS SE Kestral which fits most of your criteria. I ordered mine untested and it came perfectly set up and is one of the best finished basses I have bought and was about $1k CAD. It’s not green and is made in Korea though. My Squier has the flats but the dead rounds sounded awesome on the PRS. The only reason I changed them is because it is also the best sounding Jazz I have with new rounds. And it has bird inlays which I think are awesome.
I recently bought one of these (not very many made, but I think still some out there for sale): Fender Limited Edition American Pro Jazz Bass Natural Roasted Ash I put flats on it. Wonderful. Any arbitrary current-ish American Pro Jazz might sound the same, but I like to think the ash wood plays a role in the nice tone. I definitely thought it sounded kind of harsh with the stock roundwound strings, whereas I have an older alder-wood Jazz Bass that sounds great with roundwounds.
I have a Carvin J type bass with La Bella low tension flats that I absolutely love. You might check out Kiesel to see if anything strikes you. Also if you are handy (I’m not) perhaps a Warmoth build would allow you to customize it to perfection.
ha! i hope you're right! i'm thinking that any fender (of the fender family) expert will point you in the right direction. but at least you know what you want! TBH: i'd assemble those parameters/preferences from good/best parts, but i realize that that approach isn't for everyone. i hope you get the "jazz-ish" ax you want, OP --- good luck!
I’ve never heard of this one from PRS. It’s a beauty. I’m not too hung up on the US thing so long as it sounds/feels great. Neck thru is iffy for me, though. Not a deal-breaker, but I like the ability to swap necks easily if necessary.
My ‘78 P bass is (heavy) northern ash. I don’t know how much the body really contributes to tone, but I just know it’s the best one I’ve played to date, so maybe you’re onto something.
Yeah, I don't really know either. A proper A/B test would involve keeping everything else the same -- strings, pickups, neck, bridge -- and just swapping the body. I guess I'm not really that interested. In any case, I much enjoy this ash Jazz with flatwounds!
I’m not too handy, so I’ll probably settle for ready-made-and-assembled. I always seem to forget about Carvin. My bass teacher early on had a sweet green Carvin J variety, and if my memory serves me right, a 6 string Kiesel.
I’m not a hands-on guy, so I’ll choose something production...or the product of some other Dr. Frankenstein’s creation. Curious: my P bass is my first love, but I’ve decided I’m 51% to 49% in favor of rounds over flats on mine. Both sound great on P’s, but flats on the right Jazz sound so full, voluptuous, and rich, I think I’ve just got to have one.
i'm not sure that i can help on that: i've been a rounds player, forever. however, i'm working up the courage to break open a package of my first set of flats in 40+ years (TI jazz flats). you're probably already hip to those strings.
My G&L JB-2 has been strung with D'Addario Chromes for about 8 years. Tasty! Its a swamp ash body and it fits just right.
I just sold a used set of Jazz flats yesterday to someone in Texas. It was my third and probably final try. If you’re a committed rounds player, you stand a better chance at loving them. Actually, I do love them for what they are. They are excellent strings of the highest caliber. For the first couple of weeks I put them on, it’s a honeymoon. But the low tension and...I dunno...they are SO perfect, maybe I just like a little more vintage grunge. They intonate perfectly and express a clear fundamental. But I don’t enjoy digging into them, and if I don’t enjoy the tactile experience of playing strings, it just doesn’t work for me. But I hope their finer points woo you into the devoted TI cult. I want to be a member, but I don’t think it’s meant to be.
I have a music professor/producer friend who says once I go G&L, I’ll never go back to a Fender. Pretty strong talk: what say you?
Never really liked GL products in the ‘90s, but I’ve recently gotten an lb100 (pbass) and what’s become my ultimate Jazz type bass, a JB2. The quality of both of these is amazing. i’ve owned Fenders from 60’s,70s, as well as more recently made ones, and really find the newer GL’s a cut above. Their take on the classic alnico5 pickups sound fantastic. I’d like to try a Kiloton to check out the MFD pickup (and i love that it’s a passive bass,too). Edit:forgot to mention both basses came with the factory exl rw strings, which i thought sounded horribly shrill. I put light chromes on the lb, and labella low tension flexible flats on the Jb2. That’s 2 very different flatwound flavors,both sound much better suited to the basses to me.