1. Please take 30 seconds to register your free account to remove most ads, post topics, make friends, earn reward points at our store, and more!  
     
    TalkBass.com has been uniting the low end since 1998.  Join us! :)

What Makes The Ramones Punk and Green Day Not?

Discussion in 'Miscellaneous [BG]' started by BassGod, May 9, 2006.


  1. BassGod

    BassGod

    Jan 21, 2004
    I don't expect this thread to be pretty, but I ask this in all honesty. No troll here.

    I was thinking (uh-oh)...

    The Ramones played simple, short, three/four chord songs and wrote about things like being sedated and beating on brats.

    Green Day (Dookie-era) played simple, short, three/four chord songs and wrote about equally silly things. And their bassist was actually pretty good.

    So how come "true" punk fans consider The Ramones to be real punk, while Green Day is considered pop crap? They basically play the same kinda happy-go-lucky, loud music. If anything, Green Day is actually better at their respective instruments than the members of The Ramones.

    I'm not really a fan of either band. I'm just curious as to people's opinions on the matter. As I said, this is an honest inquiry, so keep it civil please (I know there are some very faithful punk fans out there).

    Graeme
     
  2. Smallmouth_Bass

    Smallmouth_Bass

    Dec 29, 2005
    Canada
    It probably depends on what's popular at the time. Green Day is popular and therefore probably not considered as punk because punk is not suppposed to be popular.
     
  3. d8g3jdh

    d8g3jdh Guest

    Aug 9, 2005
    I think Green Day was punk, but now they're sorta popish. I think people who call them fake are refering to what they've become, not what they once were.

    But I don't really know punk that much. For the record, most punk fans are asshats anyways.
     
  4. The recording studio, the equipment, the money.
     
  5. Well, for starters, punk-rockers are very proud, jaded individuals when it comes to their musical tastes. It's very off-putting, to be honest. I gather that once a punk-rock band hits it big and they start to see 14 year old teens going nuts for a band that they thought stood for some form of artistic rebellion, elitism kicks in and the once cherished band gets kicked out.

    That's just my opinion any case. It's also why I stopped going to punk-rock shows. I listen to any and everything that pleases my ears, I could care less about any scene stigma.
     
  6. exactly...the ramones were punk because they were something new...If the remones came out now, they'd be called posers just as much as any other "punk" or "punk-rock" band
     
  7. Matt Till

    Matt Till

    Jun 1, 2002
    Edinboro, PA
    I just don't understand how Green Day is pop punk and Ramones are just punk. They both sound (as you stated) very poppy.

    To me, the punk scene is just as fake as the posers they are trying to keep out. I try to avoid scenes.
     
  8. Ok, here's my best guess to what this is, after talking to my drummer (a really big fan.....but not in that perverted way of going to all their gigs):

    Greenday has a punk attitude, and they have a catchy upbeat style, but their songs have more structure and are more musical. That and you can't say that they would be on the same level as minor threat or Dead Kennedies. They can, however, be compared to bad religion and pennywise. Alot of their writing also variates between slow and fast whereas punk is also fast. They don't completely follow the punk vibe, but they're songs can make a comparison to other punk songs. Ok, i have no clue what I was really saying, but let's put it this way. Greenday are sorta like the Beatles: cute songs that everyone can enjoy, and they are really popular and their songs also can be compared to the beatles (in some areas folks, not as an equal). They're rock & roll INSPIRED BY punk
     
  9. lyle

    lyle Guest

    Jan 10, 2004
    Vernon, B.C. Canada
    well there was kind of the new school punk headed by fugazi and the ninties punk with pennywise and early greenday. I actaully like some early greenday good bass riffs too. But i think there dissed hard nowadays because of their latest stuff. I think they sold out a bit and mike dirnt tammed down his bass (boring)
     
  10. Woodchuck

    Woodchuck

    Apr 21, 2000
    Atlanta (Grant Park!)
    Gallien Krueger for the last 12 years!
    Green Day could actually play. :bag:
     
  11. Funky Fatcat

    Funky Fatcat

    Jul 29, 2005
    Green Day's old stuff is good. But when i listen to the radio and hear it on i don't see it as punk. In my opinion i would think it is pop...leaning kinda towards emo because come on who wears eyeliner
     
  12. havik180

    havik180

    Oct 9, 2005
    SF bay area
    Punk kinda changed with the world. People are more forgiving and accepting to certain things, so punk became edgier and had to push more boundries.

    Green Day is "just" punk enough to be accepted by so called punks but more than enough pop for your parents to even like ! Thats the problem !

    Throw in some pink accents , eyeliner , call call your latest album a "rock Opera" and you pretty much throw you punk credit out the door and make millions in the process.

    Look at a punk from then and compare them to a punk now , there really is no comparing them. I really dont get how pink and black striped arm bands make you punk !? What happened to Doc's , patches and safety pins ?
     
  13. BassGod

    BassGod

    Jan 21, 2004
    But "the look" shouldn't really be a factor, right? I mean, it's about the attitude and the music I thought. Not the image.

    Graeme
     
  14. There was a meeting. You must have missed it. Also voted "not punk" is anything that came out after 1990 and involved a mohawk.

    Mike
     
  15. in order to descern between who is punk and who isn't punk, punk, must be defined.

    i believe that we all agree that green day is no longer anywhere near what a punk band is. they were somewhere in the vicinity of what punk was, but really, it was all an act.

    punk rock was not "underground" or a new thing when green day was on the scene. really all they did was capitolize on what had already been done and continued calling it punk rock. (i do like Dirnts bass in the old stuff however)

    the ramones were the first to make "punk" popular in any way, but what punk later became known as was more of what the Dead Kennedys were doing.

    Angry sarchastic protests set to a fast beat with "hardcore" fans. it became a lifestyle and not a type of music. thats when punk rock started to die and really gained its popularity.

    every era had a different definition of punk rock, so really its all about perspective.

    green day is not by my standards punk rock.
    green day is pop punk.
    ramones are punk, but not by the same standards as the dead kennedys.

    i'm sorry if that doesn't make sense to you, it does to me.

    ramones are original, green day is a nicer sounding copy.
    simple.
    :bassist:
     
  16. havik180

    havik180

    Oct 9, 2005
    SF bay area
    True ! but what I was trying to say or show I guess is how something seems to have been lost in the music if that is kids perception of punk today. Like Good Charlotte kids all over think that they're punk and to me they're not. They make pop music for teenage girls and wear all black with make up and sh*t.

    It kinda goes hand in hand if ya think about it

    Then - mowhak , home done piercings , dirt.

    music - simple , fast , dirty and offensive to most

    Now - black hair , eyeliner , Hot Topic and cleanliness

    music - slower , emotional and ok to listen to in your moms car on the way to school
     
  17. jeff_bass28

    jeff_bass28 Guest

    Mar 21, 2006
    For me, Green Day lost all connection to "punk" when "Time Of Your Life" was used on the last Seinfeld episode. :scowl:

    A shame, too. I'm sure it wasn't their call, but...:scowl:
     
  18. Fawkes007

    Fawkes007

    Sep 13, 2005
    SF Bay Area
    A better question would be why anyone in their right mind would consider Good Charlotte to be punk.
     
  19. jeff_bass28

    jeff_bass28 Guest

    Mar 21, 2006
    Maybe it's "punk" for a 26-year old to date a 16-year old? Especially when it's Hilary Duff?
    Or maybe it's just "pathetic?"
     
  20. Matt Till

    Matt Till

    Jun 1, 2002
    Edinboro, PA
    I think the Misfits said it best when they said, "Whooaa oooohhhh ohhhhh ohhhhhh."
     

Share This Page