I am wanting to add a bass with aggressive stingrayish tone to the stable. Here are my available choices. BTW they both have to be shipped, so I can't get to do an AB comparison! I have to buy sight unseen Used MTD Kingston Artist. Pros: Light weight, comfy neck, unique shape, got the sound I am looking for, only $450 cdn Cons: I hate the amber color, I don't like basses made of basswood Sterling Ray 34 Pros: Comfy neck, close to the stingray sound, made from a more solid wood (mahogany), beautiful discontinued color Neptune Blue with maple fretboard Cons: Could be heavier than I like (bad shoulders), has been sitting new in a warehouse for 3 years, over twice the price of the MTD
Although I would personally choose the MTD Kingston, I think since you hate its color, you should go for the other one. It may sound silly, but when you don't like the look of your instrument, it's harder to bond with it and you will unconsciously find all kinds of flaws in it.
Are your choices that limited? If you're contemplating the Ray, I'd think that there should be a lot of other options in that price range. G&L Tribute L2000? They can be a little on the heavy side but they're great basses and used should be in that neighborhood. You could also look fir a used Spector Rebop. They can be really light and used should be in that price range too. I voted for the Ray cause, even though I've never owned either model. I have played each and the Ray has a much better feeling neck to me. Sounds to me like you should keep searching.
Get a used US made G&L L-1500. For example: USED G&L L-1500 Bass Blue Burst | UpFront Guitars LLC | Reverb
I’d go with the MTD if it has the sound you like. When I was shopping for a stingray I was looking at burnt apple and maple if I was buying new and a jet black with ebony showed up at a really good price. They let me rent it and it had exactly the tone I was looking for so I jumped on it and the colour grew on me. And if you really don’t like the colour you could always paint it. I’m guessing that you are looking at the MTD at L&M Edmonton North? If so I personally thought it looked a bit less like a piece of furniture in person.
Ray 34 all day: The mahogany should actually be a bit lighter than the white woods they normally use, and should just barely round off how much snark a StingRay can have just enough to have the bite a bit smoother. The Korean MM's can be giant-killers.
Yup that's the one. My biggest turn off with it is how the unevenness of the grain makes the pieces not match very well. If it was a solid color, or even a darker color like the blue or red they came in I would have snagged it by now. One of the reasons I don't like basswood is because how soft it is. The wood is soft enough that when sanding off that thick poly, guaranteed I would wreck the wood. If it was ash or maple it would be a different story
If my only option was one of those two, I voted for the MTD. Of all the basses I've owned my least favorite was the Stearling Ray 34ca. I had used it in the studio and 2 tracks in we realized the neck was twisted slightly making the first three frets on the E string the same note. Took it down to big box petting zoo and sold it.
I decided on the Ray 34QM in Neptune Blue. It was more than I wanted to spend, but I love the finish, and fretboard combo. I am just not sure which version it is. I hope it is the one with the matching headstock. Like in the pic. I remember the first of this color was swamp ash/matching hs, then they switched to mahogany with the matching hs, and finally the mahogany with the roasted maple neck which never had the painted hs Thanks for the help guys
I’m a stingray guy 100% and currently own 3 with another one arriving Friday, but I have to say that my experience with the SBMM mid range has been poor. My SUB Ray4 & Ray5 both are equal in quality and were half the cost of a Ray34/Ray35. YMMV but just my $0.02.