I find myself with 2 MIM P basses, and finances dictate that I only keep one. But which one? They are opposites, yet equal. One is the ash special edition from Guitar Center, with black pickguard and a Seymour Duncan Quarter Pounder pickup. It plays nicely, and is the brighter of the two, not to mention louder because of the pickup. The other is Arctic White with a red tort pickguard, and a Seymour Duncan Vintage P pickup. It is woodier sounding, and has a more vintage sound. It plays the same as the other one. Which one do I keep? I change my mind on this one so often, I need some advice. Thank you.