Which one should I buy!?

Hello,

I own a MIM P-Bass that I upgraded with Schaller hardware (Bridge and tuners.) Now I want to upgrade the pickups, but I am having trouble deciding which brand to buy. I live on GU, so my options are limited. I have narrowed my choices down to a Seymour Duncan Quarter-Pounder, a Seymour Duncan Lightnin' Rods P-bass replacement, or Rio Grande Muy Grande pickup. I have never owned a bass with active electronics before, so I am curious to check out the Lightnin' Rods p-up, but again, I'm not sure.
I suppose that I should include some info about me as a player. Players that I like and who influence me include Jack Cassidy, Hutch Hutchinson(sic), Andy Rourke, Geddy Lee, Chris Chaney, Robbie Shakespere, Family Man Barret, and Chris Squire. I could go on and on, but that would be overkill.
Thanks in advance for your help. Keep rockin'!!

SullyB

 

Hey all,

I have sent away for the Lightnin' Rods P-bass pickup. I checked with the Tone Wizard on Seymour Duncan's website and it suggested that for a Rock/Metal player (That's me! ) with a P-style instrument that has a rosewood neck, the best choice for me would be either the Hot P-Bass or the Lightnin' Rods. I have never owned a bass with active electronics, so I figured that I might as well give the APB-2 a shot. And anyway, if I don't like them, then I can change them out for something else. I aint skeered.

Laters,
SullyB