American Original 60’s P. The brown tort is what came from the factory. The red tort is a gorgeous celluloid guard I bought. Not sure which I like more.
I agree with you, I'm not much on black PG's except on a few colors. I also don't like pearl except on a few colors. BUT... @gsgbass's black pearl really looks good. Out of your choices, I voted brown. I'm with @bass40hz, that red hurts me as well. 057912
I like black on darker sunburst. Or on a white and maple P. I haven’t had much luck with pearloid but have seen some winners.
I like that red tort, if the brown had a bit more color to it I'd prob say the brown, but I do like the contrast on the red vs blue. Def. tort fan here... MJ