Would you quit a band if everyone but you smoked?

nope

 

honestly it wouldn't bug me so nothing its their choice and doesn't impact me in anyway

 

I don't understand. Do you have a problem with it? You didn't really clarify that. Are we talking cigarette break after every song, or like every 45 min? Everyone but me smoked in my last band and I had no problem taking a 5 minute break once in awhile.

 

Thats exactly the situation im in right now, doesn't bother me since its the story of my life, Im pretty much the only person in my immediate family that doesn't smoke so im used to it. Even if that wasn't the case thats a really small non issue.

 

There were some times in the past when I found it pretty difficult to get through a gig at a bar or restaurant because of the smoke. For instance, if I was recovering from a cold, I would have coughing fits that I couldn't overcome. The worst of the worst was at a cigar bar. That's a thing of the past thanks to smoke free workplaces in my locale.

Sitting through a rehearsal in a smoke filled basement would get old for me. If it was just outside at break during gigs, it doesn't bother me at all.

 

Yes.

 

So long as it was outside, wouldn't bother me. A 20 to 30 minute smoke break, though? That's a bit much. Sounds like they're more interested in smoking than in playing music.

 

It sounds to me like you've already made your mind up about this band.

 

In this case, yes. Kids

 

I would only worry about the return to a very old detestable practice I had years ago -- i.e tobacco. Fortunately in my current band they only smoke the crooked ones which is no temptation for me at all. Gimme a good beer any day over that catnip for humans.

 

Wait a second. First it was "occasionally taking a break during practice to go smoke". Then it was "20 minute smoke breaks after every few songs". Then by post#8, the breaks have extended to 30 minutes long.

Which is it? At this rate, they'll be taking 10 minute rehearsal breaks every couple of cigarettes!

EDIT: BTW, I'm the only smoker in my band...I don't take cigarette breaks during rehearsal. When in Rome...

 

At your age I have a very simple solution for you. Tell them that you got in trouble with your parents last time for coming home smelling like cigarettes and if it happens again they won't let you come back. That will force them to either not smoke around you in the car and they will have to decide if they really want to smoke more than they want a bass player. Also keep in mind how you will feel if you don't play with them any more, will you miss it? can you find another band? I'm a smoker myself, but I do understand how you feel.

 

Probably

 

Yes, without a second thought. I hate cigarette smoke and people who smoke tend to smell like ash trays IMO. NO offense intended.

 

Extended smoke breaks are overboard, IMHO.

'They' should be able to load up on nicotine before a gig/rehearsal, or after it's over-while taking normal breaks during the show.
(Been there, done that-out of respect for the situation/other people).

 

It shouldn't really be a big deal. Alot of musicians smoke. I realized that when I went to clinics, shows, and even plays were they had a live orchestra playing and during intermission you seen the band smoking outside.

I smoke, but I do NOT smoke during band practice. My band-mate doesn't like smoking, we practice at his house, so I give him the respect to not smoke at his house.

But if thats not the case and they are allowed to smoke where they are. It shouldn't be a problem. Maybe every 30mins to an hour they could take a break, depending on how long you guys practice. But if they take more than 15mins to smoke a cigarette, maybe its time for you to find some more dedicated musicians because It seems to me thats all they care about. The smoking scene which doesn't appeal to anyone at all. Would you want a person taking a smoke break while they perform surgery? Nope. I take band practices seriously.

 

I dont care about the smell long as its not on my stuff, I dont let my brother, mother or father smoke in my car for instance, and my bandmates maybe have one or two 5 min smoke breaks a practice, hell those are just normal breaks really, since we practice in a place we can smoke while we play, all about respect, 20 minutes is just too long, tell them if they dont like it find another bassist.