• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

FOUND THE BEEF!!!

IotaNet

Supporting Member
Dec 8, 2004
3,566
503
64
Minneapolis (Chicago Native)
A few weeks ago, I posted the following ...
Folks -

I have been tweaking/refining/changing/updating my collection lately and have been largely successful but there is a sound/tone that i hear in my head that I cannot find. :help:

My single favorite bass is my Reggie Hamilton Signature 4-string. Something about that tone is "right" ... Jazz growl but the P pickup allws me to dial in a certain "thickness" (someone else described it as BEEF) that I love the sound of. I want this same sound in a 5-string but haven't been able to find it.

... I want that thick, punchy, tone that's not boomy/thuddy. I've come to the (perhaps incorrect) conclusion that the P/J configuration is what makes this possible.

Trying to find an active 5-string P/J is turning out to be a chore. I know that the Yamaha BB615 offers this but truthfully, I've gotten spoiled by the higher build quality of my Laklands. I also know that the Yamaha preamp, while good, is not the best of breed and I am looking for a no-compromise gift for myself.

The only basses that I know of that fit what I want from a tone and quality standpoint are a Fender Reggie Hamilton V and a Sadowsky P/J 5. The Fender is an option but I don't particularly care for the Fender 5-string neck.

I'm interested in the thoughts of the Sadowsky-ites as well as those who may have other suggestions. I won't say that this is a "cost-no-object" scenario, but I am prepared to sell some basses ... to partially fund this particular aquisition.
I didn't really want to spend $3000 for a used NYC Sadowsky (although I thought long & hard about it) so I did my reasearch, trusted my instincts, and had something customized.

* I started with a Lakland JO5 w/J-Retro
* I bought a set of Nordstrand P/J pups
* Ordered an OEM pickguard from Jeannies
* Took the whole thing to my luthier and held my breath


I picked it up yesterday and I could not be more satisfied. This is EXACTLY what I was looking for! To quote my buddy, Marcus Alan, This bass delivers!!!

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]​

Understanding that my JO is a Skyline and not quite up to the build quality of a NYC Sadowsky, it cost me less than half of what the P/J Sad would have cost and I am not convinced that the extra goodness of the Sad would have been worth the extra money in this case. (Don't get me wrong -- I love my Sadowsky and am soon to own another. If there had been a Metro in this configuration, I probably would have bought it.)

With this bass, the sum of the parts come together to create something that is greater than the whole. The famous Lakland B-String, the J-Retro, and the Nordstrand Pickups work together beautifully in this bass and I couldn't be more pleased!!!

Kudos go out to Jay Lewis at Blueberryhill Bass who talked me through the pickup choice as well as Carey Nordstrand for knowing how to make a humcancelling J (as well as a 5-string P) pup that sounds awesome!

This bass is one of those "If you had to pick one and only one bass to take to a gig that you don't know WHAT the set list may be" basses. I can't imagine a situation where this bass wouldn't aquit itself beautifully.

I found the beef -- and it's quite tasty!