1. Please take 30 seconds to register your free account to remove most ads, post topics, make friends, earn reward points at our store, and more!  

4 vs 5 string when upgrading

Discussion in 'Basses [BG]' started by Jeff3298, Mar 16, 2008.


  1. Jeff3298

    Jeff3298

    Mar 15, 2008
    Concord, CA
    I currently play a 4 but wanted to get a nicer bass and I see alot of used 5 string basses for sale on CL, very few 4. Are 5 becoming less popular hence more for sale? Pros and Cons on 4 vs 5 string basses. Thanks
     
  2. El-Bob

    El-Bob

    Oct 22, 2006
    Hamilton, ON
    there's no real cons for a 5er IMO. even if you don't use the B, what do you lose? where with a 4 you may find yourself wanting the B and not having it. that's my opinion anyway
     
  3. I changed to 5 about 4 years ago. I will confess it took me about 2 years to "remap" my brain from 4 to 5 but I personally haven't regretted it at all. One nice feature about the B sting for me anyway is the ability to play a fretted low E. Hope I described that correctly. Up until then when I would play a low E it was always as an open note and if I wantd control of it I had to deal with string to mute it as I hit it. No more so now I can do both. The open E is great for a sustained note or just that woe feeling of an open plucked string, but a controlled E is very suefull as well.

    I find I use the low D a lot as well and finally if you are playing on the D string but a ways up the neck you have the ability to reach under your note for a lower octive with almost no travel.

    I recently got a 4 string to play on for back up and now realize that I don't want to play a 4 string anymore.

    All of these thoughts are just my own reflections on what works for me. You may and will have different views.

    Good plucking....
     
  4. El-Bob

    El-Bob

    Oct 22, 2006
    Hamilton, ON
    ^lots of good points there too.
     
  5. I recently switched to a 5 string. I did not have a problem adjusting to it. musicman7722 makes some good points. I would like to add Economy of motion and you can play 2 octaves in position.

    The only con I see is the strings are a bit more expensive, but that shouldn't be a a deal breaker.
     
  6. Smallmouth_Bass

    Smallmouth_Bass

    Dec 29, 2005
    Canada
    Don't get a 5-string just because it's the popular thing to do.

    Pros of 5-string:
    • More positional options (can play 4-string range in 5th position, etc...).
    • Additional low notes down to low B.
    • Don't have to detune to play stuff in Eb or D.
    • Can cover everything a 4-string can and more.

    Cons of 5-string:
    • Wider neck/not as easy to play as a 4-string (con for some, not an issue for others).
    • Have to adjust technique to make sure B-string doesn't ring. It will have a sympathetic ring if you do not mute it.
    • On many basses, you need a lighter touch on the B-string to balance the sound between the other strings.
    • Some feel the slap sound is not as good as a 4-string.
    • Many manufacturers are going to a 35" scale length for their 5-strings for added definition on the B-string. That may or may not be an adjustment you feel is comfortable or want.

    I personally prefer a 5-string. I initially started playing 5-string because I was hearing those lower notes and wanted to incorporate them into my playing. All those items I have listed as cons are not issues for me.
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.