A question about re-installing strings after breaking them.

[Euies]

I just snapped my G string after I tuned down a 4th and tuned back up (I learnt my lesson), and I've had the set of strings (my first new strings) for 20-ish days.

So, do I get new strings and replace all of them and set aside the "old" ones for spares (Which I am more inclined to do, but I'm considering getting the same strings again, so maybe take that into consideration when answering), or do I just add the G-string for now?

My current make-do is to use my old G-string. But the problem with that is that it's a .45 and the rest of my strings were .50s. It's awkward to play.

 

[noagreement]

With only 20 days on the other strings, I would just add the old G string back unless it is completely dead. That difference in gauge is small and easy to get used to again.

Buy a new set when the other strings are dead.

When I was younger and with less money, I would mix and match old sets after boiling each set multiple times! I still have a collection of countless used G strings that are available for use if something breaks. I haven't broken a string in over 20 years.

 

[Euies]

With only 20 days on the other strings, I would just add the old G string back unless it is completely dead. That difference in gauge is small and easy to get used to again.

Buy a new set when the other strings are dead.

When I was younger and with less money, I would mix and match old sets after boiling each set multiple times! I still have a collection of countless used G strings that are available for use if something breaks. I haven't broken a string in over 20 years.

It also snapped right on where the tuning peg is, I don't suppose there is a way to lengthen the string, but I suppose I can use it on either a shorter scale or a bass with 3x1 or 2x2 pegs on the headstock. It's still somewhat usable.
I think I will use a new G-string (since I have to play in a school event soon) and then replace the strings after, so I wont have to deal with the overly bright tone (I don't mind it too much on a G-string).

 

[Mystic Michael]

I've never broken a bass string in my life. I often wonder what it is about the way other players play that makes them so susceptible to string breakage. I can only assume it involves hitting those strings hard. Very hard.

Turn up the volume and lighten up your touch. Make the amp do all the hard work. Just put your fingers in the right places at the right times, and let the instrument & amp do the rest.

MM

 

[Linnin]

Both G strings snapped at the tuner? Something sinister is afoot and it is either the bass or the bass player. Not the string. Be prepared to take serious action and either burn the bass or shoot the bass player. Carry on.

 

[lz4005]

I've never broken a bass string in my life. I often wonder what it is about the way other players play that makes them so susceptible to string breakage. I can only assume it involves hitting those strings hard. Very hard.

Turn up the volume and lighten up your touch. Make the amp do all the hard work. Just put your fingers in the right places at the right times, and let the instrument & amp do the rest.
MM

OP has a sharp spot on his G tuning peg. 5 minutes with a file and he'll never break another string.

 

[Euies]

Both G strings snapped at the tuner? Something sinister is afoot and it is either the bass or the bass player. Not the string. Be prepared to take serious action and either burn the bass or shoot the bass player. Carry on.

Not "both" only one. The mistake was to tune it down to D and then tune it to G too quickly.

EDIT: I previously broke my E-string

 

[lz4005]

Not "both" only one. The mistake was to tune it down to D and then tune it to G too quickly.

Tuning down and then back up to the same pitch you started at will not break a string no matter how fast you do it. You can literally do it with a string winder on an electric drill and it won't break if you stop at G.

You either tuned it way too high or you have a sharp spot on the tuner post.

 

[rufus.K]

Just buy another G. Most places sell singles