Dear Mrs. Nuoriko,
I urge you to read this message and read it carefully. Your son may be trying to convince you to buy him a new bass, for he believes that his Kay is a heap of junk. He is saying things like a carved bass will get him a better tone and will make him sound better in the orchestra. However, he is overlooking a large aspect of the whole process, which is the player itself. You can buy a 20,000 dollar bass and if the player can't pull a nice tone out of the bass, it can sound just as bad as a 1,000 dollar bass. It is not the bass, it's the player. Granted, there are some aspects of the bass that must be addressed, such as set-up which will improve the playability and allow the musician to grow on the instrument.
What we people on Talkbass are proposing is that Brandon keep the Kay and stay away from cheap "deals" such as those found on eBay. The only reasonable upgrade in my opinion for Brandon from the Kay would be a nice 3500 dollar carved instrument like the one I have in my possession now. Any other instrument would merely be a disappointed and Brandon will feel inclined to trade it off as he grows in the future. The Kay, if properly setup and lovingly cared for, can prove to be a good instrument, despite its plywood construction. If the proper amount of care is put into restoring the instrument (which would be much less than buying a new truck or a new bass), the resale value of the instrument will grow greatly.
I understand Brandon's dilemma and I understand how he is drawn to the words, "carved" and "deal". Unfortunately, in the matter of basses, many of these "deals" prove to be a huge loss. We on Talkbass do not know your financial situation, but we can infer from previous posts that you are helping Brandon out financially in order to reach his "musical goals". The advice we are providing applies to anyone in any financial situation, selling the Kay for cheap and buying a "carved bass" under 2000 would be a huge loss. Buying a new bass seems like a viable option right now but it would require large amounts of setup work from the luthier and who knows what problems he might find that will need to be addressed for a large sum of money.
I truly hope Brandon shows this letter to you, because I have spent a lot of energy trying to guide Brandon in the right direction. I'm most invested in this because two years ago I was in the same position, trying to find an instrument that would suit me. And if not for the invaluable guidance of the esteemed gentlemen on this forum, I would have learned my lesson the hard way. I'm afraid that Brandon might end up learning his lesson the hard way if he continues not to listen to our advice.
Brandon is 14 and lucky enough to own an instrument and lucky enough to have such supportive parents that are willing to buy him a new bass and truck. However, these efforts should be going into productive investments, and such investments will not be able to be found on eBay.
The Other TB user, Clink, offered his services to accompany your son to KCStrings to try out instruments. I strongly advise you to take him up on this offer, for he knows quite a bit and is good friends with the KCStrings dealership.
I hope all the best for your son and just wish he doesn't encounter more obstacles through his yearning for a "new" bass.
Very best
Kevin Hsieh