• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass About community orchestras

Sep 24, 2011
1,335
318
Is it common practice for the conductor and the players to actually listen to a piece (together) prior to playing so to explain the subleties to the players? I have not come across it myself but would think it valuable??

Thanks for reading!
 
For me, the most valuable use of limited time with a new piece, is to play the piece from beginning to end, with as few stops as possible. Micro managing without a sense of the whole seems like a waste of time. If you are going to dissect as you listen (together) you lose the sense of the whole, and if you aren't going to dissect it, why not listen on your own time?

Steven
 
I guess it depends what concept the orchestra has of what it means to be a 'community' orchestra... is it bringing the music to the community, in which case just get on with it like any performing orchestra, or is it bringing the community in to the orchestra, in which case educational aspects might be more important.

But then, the most professional and productive rehearsal set I ever did was with the NZ National Youth Orchestra, under Michael Houston. We were doing Shostakovich 10 (think about that for a minute... a youth orchestra, nobody over 25).

Late one afternoon, Michael talked to us for 20 minutes or so about what the work was, how each movement fitted in to the overall picture, etc. Then we played it straight through, and that was all the rehearsal for the day. Next morning, we tuned up, and he rehearsed little bits and talked for three solid hours, based on notes he'd made the night before from memory (that's an impressive feat in itself). That afternoon, we played it again and it was very nearly there, and rehearsed a couple more untidy bits. We then played parts of it in the dress rehearsal, and did it for real. Best performance of anything I have ever been involved with.

Point was, talking about the concept of the work and the interpretation can be helpful.
 
I guess it depends what concept the orchestra has of what it means to be a 'community' orchestra... is it bringing the music to the community, in which case just get on with it like any performing orchestra, or is it bringing the community in to the orchestra, in which case educational aspects might be more important.

But then, the most professional and productive rehearsal set I ever did was with the NZ National Youth Orchestra, under Michael Houston. We were doing Shostakovich 10 (think about that for a minute... a youth orchestra, nobody over 25).

Late one afternoon, Michael talked to us for 20 minutes or so about what the work was, how each movement fitted in to the overall picture, etc. Then we played it straight through, and that was all the rehearsal for the day. Next morning, we tuned up, and he rehearsed little bits and talked for three solid hours, based on notes he'd made the night before from memory (that's an impressive feat in itself). That afternoon, we played it again and it was very nearly there, and rehearsed a couple more untidy bits. We then played parts of it in the dress rehearsal, and did it for real. Best performance of anything I have ever been involved with.

Point was, talking about the concept of the work and the interpretation can be helpful.


Best advice i have seen for rehearing in a long long time.