• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Add String Tension

lookjojoisplaid said:
I really dont think that getting higher gague string would help in fact i think they would have the opposite effect. I was thinking more allong the lines of lighter strings.
Wrong. Completely. Sorry.

Heavier strings require higher tension to achieve the same pitch with the same vibrating length; lighter weight strings require lower tension to achieve the same pitch with the same vibrating length.

Physics. Theory. Reality. Tested. Proven. Cannot be denied either by rational argument or emipical data. Is supported by both rational argument and emipical data.

As someone suggested, try tuning even your A string (somewhat lighter than your E) down to E. Flop city. You had to loosen it to get it down to E.
 
sethlow3 said:
Raising the action slightly, on that string only will make a world of difference in flopiness and buzzing. I promise. Try it yourself. You only need couple of mm. it sounds like.

While this will reduce fret buzz simply due to the higher action, flopiness (i.e. lack of tension) will not be affected enough to make any noticeable difference. I made a diagram of this in AutoCAD about a year ago showing the increase in scale length as action was increased. The increase in action required to increase the scale length enough to make a noteable difference was pretty massive.
 
silky smoove said:
While this will reduce fret buzz simply due to the higher action, flopiness (i.e. lack of tension) will not be affected enough to make any noticeable difference. I made a diagram of this in AutoCAD about a year ago showing the increase in scale length as action was increased. The increase in action required to increase the scale length enough to make a noteable difference was pretty massive.
Definitely agree on the fact that raising the action does not increase the scale length, and therefore tension, to any significant degree. ( sec(small angle) ~= 1 ). However, "floppy" has to do with a person's perceptions, and these are likely IMO to be more affected by hearing buzz, or by scraping the pup cover on the fingerstroke, than by the actual tension. So, I think raising the action can possibly make it "feel less floppy," at least to some degree. Too bad it make intonation worse.