I'd get a Zoom B1, B2, or B3 multi-effect unit, and try out the different effects out at a practice/rehearsal.
Even if you don't like a multi-effect unit, the experience will point you in the direction that you need to go. Then you can narrow your search down for the specific pedal that you want. And like many casual effects users, you may find that the multi does the job just fine.
Even if you don't like a multi-effect unit, the experience will point you in the direction that you need to go. Then you can narrow your search down for the specific pedal that you want. And like many casual effects users, you may find that the multi does the job just fine.