Alkali Ike
Gold Supporting Member
- Jan 1, 2011
- 2,854
- 15,665
- Disclosures
- I never actually learned to play very well
How do you know Paul's was the BGV harmonies?Maybe John sang the BGV harmonies!
"Baby's in Black" was recorded on 11 August 1964, and was the first song recorded for Beatles for Sale.[8] Lennon and McCartney sang their vocal parts simultaneously through the same microphone. This was done at their own insistence in order to achieve a closer feel to the performance. McCartney was subsequently contacted by their music publisher in 1964 inquiring as to which melody line was the main tune (i.e., Paul's higher or John's lower melody). McCartney later said that he told the publisher they were both the main melody.[9]
George's elegant guitar leads were always just right, IMO. I gather that he put a lot of work, which went mostly overlooked, into making them sound so "effortless".
Since hearing so much about Ringo's drumming techniques on SiriusXM's Beatles Channel this week, due to his recent birthday, I've also gotten a new appreciation for his serendipitous addition to the group. He wasn't just a steady timekeeper, but actually came up with some 'once in a lifetime' signature song-making beats, in addition to all the overlooked many and varied essential fills! FIRE THE DRUMMER!?! I'm not sure The Beatles would have been quite so big if Brian Epstein hadn't.
.
I suspect he worked hard on those leads. I don’t think he was a “natural”. But he made them seem effortless.
One of the reasons I prefer the stereo mixes is because all the instrumental parts tend to stand out so clearly in one channel or the other. They’re more buried in the mono mixes. But that’s just me.
Last edited:
Maybe John sang the BGV harmonies!
