Being a fellow gigging Ohioan, I can say from experience that I've run into this a lot. Many clubs around Pittsburgh PA are like this, and I've run into clubs in Cincinnati OH, Covington KY, Kent OH, and Cleveland asking the same sort of things. Maybe it's a regional thing?
It just depends on how bad you want to play there. If it's a big-time club that has national acts often, it's probably worth it to play a night for free, but if it's "Joe Schmoe's Hole In A Wall" I'd pass.
Although, I will say that even if we're talking about a national-act type of club, that doesn't guarantee that it's worth doing this. Peabody's in Cleveland is the most shady, back-stabbing, bull****ting venue I've ever played. They have big-time acts, so my band wanted in. We're from about 3hr45min from Cleveland so it was a big ordeal for us, but we thought it was worth it. We did a battle of the bands, where the guy in charge promised us a weekend gig if we sold at least 50 tickets out of 100 (at $8 a pop, none of which we were allowed to keep!). Well, we sold all of them. We went there, played, kicked @$$, had a ton of devoted fans from our area make the long trip just to see us play that show, won and went on to the finals, and in the end got nothing. They made probably around $1300 just from my band's ticket sales for the 2 shows, and then didn't even offer us a gig! If selling out of tickets for an over-priced show almost 4 hours away and actually BRINGING a big crowd that far for a show doesn't prove that your band is deserving of a gig, I don't know what else is.
Sorry for the rant, just saying that there are no guarantees. This unpaid audition thing might be worth it, it might not. I wish you the absolute best of luck, though. I've never played up in Toledo, but I'd love to be up that way permanently. It's not TOO TOO far from Chicago, Detroit, Cleveland, Columbus, etc... all of which have thriving music scenes. The metal scenes in those cities, for instance, are some of the strongest in the nation, not to mention I've heard a lot of good about Toledo itself. My aunt and uncle live in Erie, Michigan, which is across the state line from Toledo, and I've been contemplating a move up that way. Though it sounds like getting a gig might be a pain.
