• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

BEST P-BASS PASSIVE PICKUP?

Is there a bad split pickup? If so, I've never heard it. There are different flavors, but they're all pretty sweet.
I just noticed that this is an old thread but I’ll reply to this comment anyway. The original P pickup on my 80’s MIJ PBass was.... meh. I replaced it with the Nordstrand NP4v that I mentioned previously, and it’s never coming out of that P while I’m breathing. Sweet, smooth pickup.
 
I recently got an 80's Fender '57 Reissue with the P pickup with the raised A pole pieces. The tone is fine by me, but my fingers catch it all the time, so I was thinking about replacing it just so I can play without snagging my fingers on those pole pieces. Any recommendations for the same '57 reissue tone but without the raised pole pieces? I realize there are tons of options these days, but I was wondering if anyone else had this same experience and if so, what they swapped the original pickup out for? Thanks TB'ers!

I recently got a AVRI 57 too and I noticed a lot of growl with this pickup. I also have a ''hard'' touch when playing fingerstyle. I still like the even sound of the original pickup but simply wondering if someone found a better sounding pickup! :cool:
 
EMG Geezer is my favorite. but it's on the total opposite side of the tone spectrum compared to the quarter pounder.

Heya LammChop... Can you say a bit more about the differences? I've got a EMG Geezer in my G. Gould (first P-style bass I have ever owned!) and I like it a lot (but still miss the focused tone of an MM-style in the sweet spot).
 
Q1GmiOh.jpg
 

Latest posts