• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Breaking Bass Stereotypes

cliff burton played a Ric, so I think that's pretty well-suited to metal. But Roger Waters played one (psychedelic rock) and so did Chris Squire (pop), but I've never seen a jazz bassist play one. It's a different sound, and that's really what matters.

I suppose that depends if you consider Stanley Clarke a jazz bassist or not. Wiki does, but YMMV. Same with Chris Brubeck
 
Michael Amott is the founder of Carcass and Lead Guitar for Arch Enemy.

whoa whoa whoa! no no no! he joined carcass didn't found them... but jeff walker did use something odd on this tour.... hang on


carcass-10.jpg


that! ^ what is that?
 
cliff burton played a Ric, so I think that's pretty well-suited to metal. But Roger Waters played one (psychedelic rock) and so did Chris Squire (pop), but I've never seen a jazz bassist play one. It's a different sound, and that's really what matters.

Chris Brubeck (Dave Brubeck's son) played a fretless Rick when playing with his dad. I thought that was pretty out there, but the sound was actually pretty nice. He migh have had flats or nylon tapewounds on.

As an aside, my high school music teacher played with a guy who played a Rick with nylon tapewounds for rock, and he said it was one of the best bass tones he'd ever heard. Go fig.

-Mark

N.B. I missed Sartori's post. Oh well. :(
 
i would really enjoy to see a band with a black tama drumkit, all esp, ibanez and jackson gear and start playing something really soothing and gentle with all that gear.

people use all kind of things. if you see any contemporary reggae band, they probably play über-expensive 6 string active basses. in the old times, the guys played jazz basses or just anyhing that they had available.

it sounds good in both ways.
 
I'm glad I no longer mess with genres that spend more time caring about image than practicing.
I'm glad the lot of you think I care more about image than talent.

Boy I wish I was ninteen again. I just down have time to give a crap anymore....
If you actually read the post, I just stated that some basses are better for certain genres. I was talking about tone-wise not image-wise.

There is not enough deviation in how Basses look to go on about what Bass follows what look best, and it is not like the crowd will ever notice what you are playing in the first place.
 
A Warwick Thumb/$$ playing through an overdriven Mesa in Jazz pop is going to be just as out of place as a fretless acoustic Bass in eardrum-shattering Metal.

Acoustic Bass in a Metal Band?. Hey along with an acoustic guitar and some brushes on the drums, imagine that a metal band you can actually hear and understand the vocals on.
Although understanding the vocals may not necessarily be a good thing.
 
Acoustic Bass in a Metal Band?. Hey along with an acoustic guitar and some brushes on the drums, imagine that a metal band you can actually hear and understand the vocals on.
Although understanding the vocals may not necessarily be a good thing.
If it was all acoustic then it wouldn't be "eardrum-shattering" now would it?

My point was a bass that was too aggressive in a mellow setting would be distracting, while a mellower Bass in a heavy music setting would not be heard at all.


P.S. I can understand most metal vocalists just fine.
 
i used to play in a ska band with a maverick nemisis that was not only black and spikey but had upside down crosses as inlays and pentagrams on the pickups it looked very odd but sounded great and there's nothing more amusing than watching a bass that looks fresh out of a dimmu borgir video playing rat race by the specials :bassist:
 
If it was all acoustic then it wouldn't be "eardrum-shattering" now would it?

My point was a bass that was too aggressive in a mellow setting would be distracting, while a mellower Bass in a heavy music setting would not be heard at all.


P.S. I can understand most metal vocalists just fine.

It was a joke son. I understood your point and your point about the lyrics. My mama used to tell me she couldn't understand a word Elvis was saying.

I'd heard all the jokes about only needing 3 chords in RnR too and found it absurd. Then I went to a KISS concert and W.A.S.P. opened with only 2 chords per song and the most annoying blaring garbage I had ever heard. Kiss was fun and pretty well polished by then

I'd watch the eardrum-shattering levels though.