• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Budget short scale for Motown?

Bronco vs Shortscale Jaguar

I have both. I bought a cheap used Bronco, modded the crap out of it, and turned it into a Musicmaster. I bought a new CAR Jag, sight unseen over the internet, because I was too cheap to buy what I really wanted, a CIJ Competition Mustang.

I don’t think I would have bought the Jag if I’d had a chance to play it first because the neck is so skinny; it’s like playing a tooth pick. Plus the fret ends were so sharp you could have shaved with them. I took it to two different luthiers to get it to play right without buzzing and to fix the frets. This was more $$$ than I’d planned to invest because I didn’t buy it to mod, with the exception of the weak J pup.

The Bronco was for modding, so I did get a fret level and dress, along with changing all electronics, pg, knobs, tuners, and pups. The Bronco neck feels like a bass neck, kind of P bassish in feel.

With all that said, I do love my Jag now because I played it enough to get use to the thin neck. In fact I like it better at this point than the Bronco, because I haven’t spent much time playing the Bronco yet, plus it needs a setup. Many LG scale players here on TB have said the JAG feels more like a toy, and I understand what they mean, because it does take some getting use to, but once you do, it’s a sweet instrument.
I’m running half rounds on the Jag, and haven’t decided what strings for the Bronco yet, but right now I’m using the original Jag strings on it, and I agree with JummyM that either can be used to play Motown.

057912
 
Kala U Bass. Really short scale, incredible playability, and has the Motown thump in spades. The one downside to it is that there aren't too many other tones in it besides the Motown thump, so if she gets into Rush, she may have to buy another bass.
 
I'll put another vote for a mustang with flats. the jaguar ss neck is just about the thinnest fastest neck i've ever played but the bass is just not very good, not as good as a mustang anyway. the mustang's got a good tone of it's own and has simple controls.

worst case, just get the smallest most comfortable bass she can find and put some foam under/around the strings at the bridge.
 
I'll put another vote for a mustang with flats. the jaguar ss neck is just about the thinnest fastest neck i've ever played but the bass is just not very good, not as good as a mustang anyway. the mustang's got a good tone of it's own and has simple controls.

worst case, just get the smallest most comfortable bass she can find and put some foam under/around the strings at the bridge.

+1 on the Mustang. Though I like my SS Jaguar (it's on "permanent" loan to a good friend), the Mustang is my favorite.

The Mustang has a strung-through-body bridge, so it takes medium (32") scale Chromes, short TIs ("short" TIs are for a 32" scale) or the special LaBella Mustang flats. Chromes and TIs are flexible enough to work with the strung-through bridge. LaBella recommends against using their standard flats with a strung-through bridge (that's why they make a special set for the Mustang).

The SS Jaguar is not strung-through body, which may account for some of the tone difference. Use 30" scale strings on the SS Jaguar. I have Chromes on mine and it has what I'd call a fairly "traditional" tone with the bridge PU rolled completely off and the tone knob rolled off about 1/3 turn back from full treble.

Both basses need a bit of bass boost at the amp to get closer to the P-bass tone, but either one should work just fine for R&B (Motown or Stax).
 
Hi

isn't the Mustang much more Epensive?The ss Squire has two pick ups.That's better, isn't it ? Never tried a Mustang.Considering these points ,is it still that much better.? If so I wish I would have tried one.The price on the ss Squier was a major factor for me.

Thanks

Davesound
 
Hi

isn't the Mustang much more Epensive?The ss Squire has two pick ups.That's better, isn't it ? Never tried a Mustang.Considering these points ,is it still that much better.? If so I wish I would have tried one.The price on the ss Squier was a major factor for me.

Thanks

Davesound

The Squier Mustang is $100 more than the SS Jaguar. They are both excellent values as well as capable players. Lots of folks buy them as modding projects, but they are just fine stock. The single-coil bridge pickup on the Jag is a bit noisy, but I've always kept it rolled off. If I hadn't fallen for the Mustang, I would have changed it out for a split-coil Jazz pickup.

If buying a Mustang would prevent the OP's friend from affording a good set of flatwound strings, then she should get the Jaguar. Otherwise, I think she should try both of them.