• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Can't come up with basslines

I sat down and listened for a while to the mp3 on repeat and I finally managed to come up with something... for the first song. I guess I'll have to do that again for the other one until I can find another bassline in my head.

On the unrelated topic of recording and mp3s, whenever I record something on audacity it sounds like its an octave lower for some reason?

It's been a long time since I used audacity so not sure why it would sound an octave lower. Maybe try Reaper to see if it happens there. Reaper is free to try and is much more powerful compared to Audacity in my experience.
 
1) Try singing bassline ideas
2) If you can do the above, lay down scratch tracks of your song and program (yes, I said program lol) the bassline with a bass vsti so you can hear it back. Use the MIDI Scroll to change notes around and try different ideas

This is what I do
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mrtoodamnsabre
Don't overthink it. Relax and explore each song. Record practices and you will figure out which ideas work (and which ones do not). I like The Stranglers for bass lines that move and are aggressive but fit the song. Maybe that fits within the post punk mold you mentioned OP.

 
  • Like
Reactions: swink
If you’re writing the rest of the music, what I usually use as a rule of thumb on where to go. The Rhythm of the drum part, the vocal melody and when and where the bass and guitar should be syncing up or if there’s a need to at all.
Another bare bones way to go. Match up with the guitar and play the percussive rhythm of the drums and branch out to compliment the vocal part.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nicolas Moreno
I absolutely suck at music theory, I can play scales instinctively but I can't put a name to any of them and I don't know how to use them.



I started paying about 4 years ago but I only really started practicing seriously and playing live last year. My main problem is that, whatever I play always ends up sounding like someone else's song, and when it doesn't it's usually pretty basic and uninteresting or just playing root notes lol
I was like that the first 8 years of playing bass, then it started to all gel for me. I played in originals bands for about 10 years after that. Even started being a songwriter myself.

Be patient. It’ll come eventually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nicolas Moreno
Glad you got a start. It's complicated, but you'll draw from your influences, you'll be working within what sounds right within whatever the style is of what you're writing on guitar, and once in a while hopefully something may come out that is your own thing.

It depends on what you're style is, which I don't know, but I think the best thing is to start by ear, feel, and letting your own head sound it out. Keep listening or playing it in your head. It may come while you're doing something mundane with headphones on. Then sit and play.
 
you gotta listen to alot of good basslines, and learn them to see how they are constructed. you'll eventually learn the building blocks of a good bass line. also learn your scales and chords as most great basslines utilize them in one way or another. Many bassists skip learning chords, but when i finally picked that up it changed my game completely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nicolas Moreno
I played many years in a prog rock trio that did all originals - sometimes grooves came easy, but when they didn't I'd just ask myself "what would <xxxx> do?" - which for me was usually Jaco, Geddy or Geezer. It helps to be able to quickly remember what you like about how your inspirational bassist play, and then try to make your own contribution. Hope this helps. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nicolas Moreno
After months of being a cover band I finally convinced the rest of my bandmates that we should start writing our own songs. I already had a few ideas in my head and I started writing the parts for guitar, drums and even the lyrics, but I just can't come up with a decent bassline to go with it all. Is there no alternative other than sticking to the same 4 notes? How do you come up with basslines, and why is it so much easier to write guitar parts?

Any and all tips are appreciated
Learn the major scale and which chords are in which key; it will help a lot. Theory doesn't limit us but shows us how to play better. I've been writing punk songs in classical modes. They've given me more chord riffs and basslines than ever.
 
I played many years in a prog rock trio that did all originals - sometimes grooves came easy, but when they didn't I'd just ask myself "what would <xxxx> do?" - which for me was usually Jaco, Geddy or Geezer. It helps to be able to quickly remember what you like about how your inspirational bassist play, and then try to make your own contribution. Hope this helps. :)

This does actually help a lot but at the same time when I try doing things like this I just don't understand why certain bassists do the things they do, or what they are doing at all hahaha.

In any case I managed to come up with a bassline by just taking the guitar part and playing around with it to get something different that fit the mood, but I'll remember all of this advice for the next one.