Compressor or High Pass Filter?

[Low Key]

I didn't realize so many people use a high pass filter or that that was even a thing. Something to ponder!

It caught be by surprise as well. It wasn't until I started using an amp with an onboard HPF that I realized how much it can extend EQing options. When something seemed boomy or muddy, I used to boost and cut EQ bands as the first solution. Now I start with the HPF to remove the undesirable lows and it frees up the EQ to tweak other areas.

 

[ComeHomeShane]

Both.

 

[Mosthigh]

@S.F.Sorrow said:"And finally, without hearing you play we can't rule out the possibility that this is simply caused by poor playing technique, in which case the solution is PRACTICE."

I don't doubt my technique is part of the problem, I'm just trying to buy my way out of it.

 

[GrooveTheory]

Both would probably be good. Light compression, followed by a HPF to cut any undesirables. A single pedal solution though could be the new Diamond Bass Comp/Eq. It doesn’t have a HPF, but it does have a post-compressor eq tilt (slight turn to the will right cuts lows and boost some highs.). Would probably be just right for what you’re looking to accomplish!

 

[PBO Blues]

...I don't doubt my technique is part of the problem, I'm just trying to buy my way out of it.

Oh yeah, aren't we all?

 

[Maxi Funkl]

Anyone around here use the Walrus Audio Mira on bass?

 

[metron]

I'm trying to even out the low end on my '67 Guild Starfire. The highs are nice and full, but I get spikes in the lower frequencies due to the 14K output Bisonic, and, (mostly) my own sloppy playing. My JBL K140 cab is also sensitive to too much low end. I use vintage tube amp heads like a Sunn 200S and a Fender Dual Showman.
I'm running into a MXR 10 band eq into a TC Spark Booster and a WIIO clone. While the eq helps, I still want a certain amount of vintage wooly bassiness, but without the spikes.

Although I have zero experience with them, I know compressors like the Cali76 Bass have a HPF, but was thinking I might get the job done with a HPF alone. Or maybe a compressor/limiter like the Keeley Bassist.

Based on your description of low frequency spikes and a cab that’s sensitive to low end, I recommend a HPF. The combo H/LPF works great too. I run dirts into a combo filter then a comp. There is a lot you can do with the pair.

I like the Keely but it does trigger a lot more on low notes without the filter out front. Its so transparent that I don’t find it a big deal though.

 

[ThinCrappyTone2]

These are a must have for me.
View attachment 5216211

That board cries out for 6-10 more pedals

 

[rubytopaz]

I didn't realize so many people use a high pass filter or that that was even a thing. Something to ponder!

Discovering the HP Filter totally improved my sound.