I live in the sticks of southern Washington state. Portland, OR is about an hour away. Getting a delivery in WA means paying sales tax. Picking it up in Portland saves the tax, but is a minimum of three hours, and $15-20 in gas.
Add some more time for a Costco run.
Do the math, and it makes sense to have anything used, that might be a reject, shipped to the N Portland store and pick it up during the next Costco run. Same for anything that would incur $20 or more in sales tax. They will hold the item until I get there.
A recent order through
Musicians Friend ended up going through the local GC anyway. They did OK. Not perfect, but OK. A follow up call to get the stuff like, trem bar, truss rod and intonation wrenches, manual, and any other case candy that should have come with a new guitar, never got me anything. The guitar was repackaged, but packed well enough and arrived on schedule. Was it 100% spanking brand new? Maybe. Close enough at the discounted price for my purpose.
Follow up on the missing accessories: fail. I ordered a bar from the manufacturer. I’m good.
Other orders on new gear to be picked up in store went just fine. Ordered for open box, scratch and dent deals and discounted gear went fine.
About what you’d expect from any retailer these days. If things go right, great. If they have and issue, good luck with anything besides taking it back to the store for a return.