Years ago I brought my P to the music store to get set up (I didn’t do that back then) and asked for LowRiders to be put on it, but they were out and had the Jonas Hellborgs, so I just went with them. (I only play rounds)
Before I left the store I picked up a Jazz V off the wall and got hooked on fivers, and didn’t even play the P when I got it back.
A couple years later after a band rehearsal I went into the main house for a smoke and the others were just jamming in the music room.
Well suddenly I hear this absolutely GLORIOUS bass in the mix, and I’m like whaaa!!!
One of the guys dug out the ol’ P (he liked bass but didn’t like fivers).
I’m not sure if it was the P or the strings or a combination, but how it sat in the mix never left my brain to this day.
I’m recently playing a P-5 now that they came out with the Squier version, but I still don’t hear that beautiful sound I remember.
I haven’t thought about it ‘till this thread, and I really should A/B them and see how different they sound out of the same rig.
If they made those strings for fivers, I think I’d have them on all my basses.