• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Drop D or D Standard Tuning

Which D tuning is better for you?

  • Drop D (DADG)

    Votes: 31 52.5%
  • D Standard (DGCF)

    Votes: 28 47.5%

  • Total voters
    59
  • Poll closed .
I ended up getting Ernie Ball 2831 Power Slinky 55-75-90-110, and while I have no comparison with anything else, they seem fine. I've yet to hook up my bass to an amp, nor do I know how a bass should sound. What an interesting journey this will be. All my guitars are tuned to standard D, that's why I needed the same tuning on my bass (if anyone is wondering why I just don't use drop D).
 
D standard. We drop everything down to Eb, which is useful (cheating?) for vocals and such...

That's not cheating.. I find that most rock and pop music with male singers are written around chords like C, D, Dm, E, F, G, A, Am,Hm which in standard tuning in a rock band setting suits a bright baritone. But even those bright baritones when they get up past 45 years of age they start tuning down a half step.. This basically happen for most singers on a lot of their material,,Bruce Springsteen, Bono, Elton john, Billy Joel..
I am a deep baritone and E-flat is closer in pitch for my voice.. But it is actually slightly too high.. At 440Hz i need to do weekly exercises and be 100% focus on vocal techniques when singing high around the second passaggio.. I need the pitch lowered to 435Hz (-20 cents) before I feel comftable with singing very high for my vocal fach (deep baritone)...

Only read further is this topic has interest (for vocalist)....

Most male singers get worn out by singing high through the second passaggio (break) at 440Hz for so many years... The entire new age 432Hz thing on the net is probably bogus.. But 432Hz or (-31.77 cents) have a nice relaxed resonance and keeps a certain note from flipping into head..Here is an old video with superstar opera bariton Pireo Cappuccilli demonstrate the difference between 432Hz and 440Hz tuning., He says watch out for the D#4, at 432Hz tuning he can sing it completely below the break (second passsagio).. At 440Hz he has to shift towards head resonance.. "change register"..Warning the video quality is really bad...

Here is another video demonstrating verdi tuning at 432Hz on a choir..
just compare the money note at 15.10 (432Hz ) to 20.47 (440Hz).. This is the flip note of F#4/F#5 (tenor/soprano)...

THis forced early transition when A4 is tuned to 440Hz is what makes less trained singers "pull chest" and "scream" on high notes.. lower the pitch to 431Hz (-35.88 cents) and the phenomen is basically eliminated.. And there is no need to lower the song the extra 64 cents to get to G#4=415.3Hz (-100 cents)...
 

Latest posts