i play a knutson messenger bass with helicore pizz strings (light gauge). i like them pretty well, and they sound even over most of the bass, but when i play the D on the g string in the thumb position (or any note higher) you cant hear it at all while the band is playing. in the practice room there's not much difference because i'm right on top of the speaker. why is this happening? i'm thinking that even though they're light strings they still feel kind of stiff on my bass and maybe since i'm stopping the string so high and the string length is so short at that point then maybe there's not enough ampitude to the string so therefore no volume. should i try a lighter string? i do alot of playing in that range so this is very important to me.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Double Bass eub strings?
- Thread starter shwashwa
- Start date
In my opinion, on a EUB, you'd probably get even less volume with a lighter string of the same type. I'd try the mediums instead.
I have no experience with the helicore pizz, but he Helicore Hybrids are probably the loudest string I tried. Maybe the hybrids light D&G?
Other than that, could it be related to the Messenger's sensor design?
Did you discuss the problem with Mr. Knutson?
If it's really a string problem, you may need to experiment with mix and match, but it may be expensive.
Since you play a lot at thumb position, I guess you'd rather play a lower tension string.
You can find low tension strings, with a strong volume, in the gut or synthetic core categories.
I find the Oliv and Eudoxa have high output and easy to play, but are expensive.
I've recently discover, and fell in love, with the Innovation braided (140B series) solo G.
Warm tone yet singing, strong volume, good articulation, and affordable. (and more stable and durable than gut)
Hope this helps!
François
I have no experience with the helicore pizz, but he Helicore Hybrids are probably the loudest string I tried. Maybe the hybrids light D&G?
Other than that, could it be related to the Messenger's sensor design?
Did you discuss the problem with Mr. Knutson?
If it's really a string problem, you may need to experiment with mix and match, but it may be expensive.
Since you play a lot at thumb position, I guess you'd rather play a lower tension string.
You can find low tension strings, with a strong volume, in the gut or synthetic core categories.
I find the Oliv and Eudoxa have high output and easy to play, but are expensive.
I've recently discover, and fell in love, with the Innovation braided (140B series) solo G.
Warm tone yet singing, strong volume, good articulation, and affordable. (and more stable and durable than gut)
Hope this helps!
François
here are some strings i have that i can try... spirocore weich. spiro core solo, spirocore regular (red) but i didnt like them when they were on there. corelli (lightest gauge), labella black nylon (they're stiff), kolstein heritage (perlon core), out of these strings which ones would you try first? just a reminder. the strings that are on sound fine, and the g sounds fine too, just in that one range it's lacking. the others sound fine in the high thumb position...
which one of the above strings would you imagine to have the most sustain in the messenger?
thanks
which one of the above strings would you imagine to have the most sustain in the messenger?
thanks
Since I don't like Spiros, and since the Corellis are the lightest gauge, I'd try the Heritage. (also because I really want to try them sooner or later...)
But I have no idea if they'd give you the sustain you seem to want.
My feeling is that your problem doesn't come from the strings but your Messenger's sensor.
Didn't I read somewhere that he changed the sensor design recently and could retrofit older basses?
I'd write him to get his opinion on your issue at [email protected]
I can only provide feelings about your problem since I never tried a Messenger EUB, and my taste with strings being more on the orchestral type of sound.
But I have no idea if they'd give you the sustain you seem to want.
My feeling is that your problem doesn't come from the strings but your Messenger's sensor.
Didn't I read somewhere that he changed the sensor design recently and could retrofit older basses?
I'd write him to get his opinion on your issue at [email protected]
I can only provide feelings about your problem since I never tried a Messenger EUB, and my taste with strings being more on the orchestral type of sound.
thanks, i'll contact him, but i dont think he has modified the pickup. i have the barbera on it, and its fine on my 2 uprights that i have it on... and if it werent working correctly then the whole g string would sound different, not just a few notes in a certian range...
In that case it may just be a case of uneven instrument response.shwashwa said:
If you find a string with a stronger output at thumb position, there are many chances it'll sound too loud in lower positions, so your problem won't be solved...
Anyway, I wish you good luck with your quest, I can't help more!
I have 380m on one of my Staggs and due to almost equal string heights because of a conceptually wrong bridge arc, the higher string feel rather hard (high tension) compared to the lower ones. I once tried them on my double bass, but even there I felt that the higher strings have more tension than I like (on a 110 cm scale).
Might work with a rather low string height, but only on the higher strings because the lower ones need room to vibrate.
Might work with a rather low string height, but only on the higher strings because the lower ones need room to vibrate.
