LajoieT said:
To me the Skylines devalued the Lakland brand in my mind
Ehhh, I personally don't think so... see below...
(this was before I joined TB, so I really didn't know the difference)
Well, maybe this might be why you feel the way you do, maybe not, but just in case, the diffs are all purely high end luthier type stuff that makes it a much higher quality piece of work, but not really that much better of an instrument from a functionality perspective.
As such, the markets for the USA line and the Skyline don't really intersect, IMHO, so I don't see one threatening the other at all. In fact, again, I'm the perfect example. In my case, it was a Skyline or no Lakland. I'm very happy the Skylines are there! Also, I may "upgrade" to a USA model someday, but in the mean time, I'm still enjoying the majority of that classic Lakland playability, sound, and look. On the flip side, if I was really looking for the "real deal" and had that kind of coin to drop on it, I'd never even consider the Skyline, so again, one line doesn't threaten the other.
In both cases, you DO get what you pay for... it just depends on what you're willing to pay for exactly what... as always.
and I don't see the advantage of doing that to other brands like F, Fodera, Alembic, etc. There are enough decent (or less than) basses with big names on them made by these other companies, we don't need to give them another.
Since I consider them to be more introductory to a given brand/model, as opposed to a market blurring alternative, I do view the presence of this kind of product line to be advantageous.
Just my opinion, and I mean no disrespect or anything Vics (Not sure if you recognize me or not, but we've been in several of the Cirrus Discussions together and we seemed to see pretty eye to eye on those...).
NO PROBLEM! Hey, my opinion is just like anyone else's... an opinion, and as long as somebody doesn't flame me for it, I'm very cool with diffs of opinion, and don't take them as slams. If we all had the same viewpoint, TB would be too boring to continue.