• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Growliest, harshest Jazz pickups?

David Sims just had some rando-cheapo pickups in a Memphis J copy, correct? (or whatever came in the Memphis). Love his tone.
I have a similar Memphis 70s Jazz from the same era, except with a maple neck/black body + blocks, binding. Great and solid bass in general with a killer neck but the original pickups were terrible and fragile (I don't even think they were hum-cancelling with both pickups on, but that could have been my near-identical Ibanez from the same era and probably same factory). The electronics in most of the 70s Japanese Fender copies were by far the weakest link of even the "top of the line" versions like my Memphis and Ibanez basses. Frankly hard to believe if they had lasted in his bass for all the years he gigged it.

I replaced the pickups in my Memphis with a set of the old Squier "Duncan-Designed" pickups that used to come in the Vintage Modified Jazz basses, and that bass just rips! The Duncan-designed pickups were just import versions of the Seymour Duncan SJB-1 pickup set, which are fantastic aggressive traditional Jazz singles as long as you put them in a naturally aggressive bass (the Memphis is very much that!). They used to pop up used on Ebay on a fairly regular basis for cheap when people were trying to "upgrade" their Squiers, but they haven't been the stock pickups for years now so you see them far less often. A great deal if you can find them, but the US made SD SJB-1 sets are also very reasonably priced for the quality IMO.
 
To the OP, the varied posts show that there will always be "Your Mileage My Very" attached to a subject that at its core deals with tone... all I'm going to say is you can undo what is done. I love fiddling with stuff like this...

Yeah this is a tough choice with all of these options, especially since I can’t hear any of them beyond YouTube clips.

Right now I’m leaning towards either the Tom Brantley Geddy Lee or the Seymour Duncan Hot Stack.
 
Like the title says I’m trying to find some really growly pickups for my jazz bass. The Fender vintage 60s that came stock are a little too mellow for my liking.

I’d like to keep the mids up and maybe throw some humbuckers in there. Passive and not straying too far from sounding like a jazz bass would probably be ideal.
Before you buy anything, try bypassing the volume and tone pots; connect the pickups straight to the jack. Doing this will make your bass sound less smooth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tindrum
I second a string change. I used nickel rounds on both Jazz basses for years and recently tried Roto 66's stainless steel (thanks TB) on my one jazz bass. Wow, what a difference. A new set of SS strings might just be the ticket.
I hate to lead someone else down the rabbit hole, but I think experimenting with different strings makes a bigger difference than most pickup swaps.
 
I second a string change. I used nickel rounds on both Jazz basses for years and recently tried Roto 66's stainless steel (thanks TB) on my one jazz bass. Wow, what a difference. A new set of SS strings might just be the ticket.
I ordered the Roto 66’s as per a recommendation of an earlier TBer. Will be here tomorrow and I’ll report back on if that helps me out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Low Commotion
These have all been great suggestions. New strings ordered. Going to teach myself more about pots and wiring. I’m really liking the tone that I’m hearing from those Geddy Lee rewinds. Might not be the growliest suggested but they sound great. If I go for more growl I think I’ll pick up the SD Hot Stacks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tindrum
These have all been great suggestions. New strings ordered. Going to teach myself more about pots and wiring. I’m really liking the tone that I’m hearing from those Geddy Lee rewinds. Might not be the growliest suggested but they sound great. If I go for more growl I think I’ll pick up the SD Hot Stacks.

You get the pickups that cover the sonic range you're shooting for then strings and technique will go a long way in getting you where you want sound wise...