• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Headstock comparison survey

Which is your favorite headstock design?

  • Lakland

    Votes: 89 28.7%
  • Sadowsky

    Votes: 106 34.2%
  • Valenti

    Votes: 25 8.1%
  • Mike Lull

    Votes: 26 8.4%
  • Alleva Coppolo

    Votes: 22 7.1%
  • Nordstrand/Nordy

    Votes: 42 13.5%

  • Total voters
    310
If Bacchus was an option, that's how I
would have voted...

Sadowsky- The "Shmoo" character for The Flintstones. Really not that
bad looking, but that's what I see every time I look at one.

Valenti- All I see is a neighing Horse, or a Sea Horse Head. I've
heard great things of Nino's basses, but I just can't get past that
headstock...

...Just my opinion.

Weren't "Shmoon" from the "Lil' Abner" comic strip, not the much later Flintstones?
See: Invalid Link Removed

Also, to me, the Valenti headstock has a little gentle V at the end of the it.
Kinda a peace symbol or a V for victory ala Churchill...
See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Churchill_waves_to_crowds.jpg
I thought everyone knew that! :D :D :D
 
Sorry to break it to you but this is the original. :D ;)
so I guess it can be beat. ;)
Image389.jpg

Wasn't it inspired by Mearl Travis Guitars? Perhaps, "Leo got it right" should be replaced with "Leo made this famous, but someone else did it first."

That was the Bigsby "Merle Travis" guitar and it looked much more like the later Fender headstock:''

guitar_headstock_220.jpg


And if people really want to pick nits about which was the original, the one below pre-dated Fender by 16 years:
Headstock of the 1935 Audiovox #736 Electric Bass.

Invalid Link Removed


BTW, my favorite 2+2 headstock is the Dano "coke bottle" style.
 
The Sadowsky headstock must be the ugliest in the history of the world. It looks totally ridiculous. Like if it was "designed" by a three year old child. The Lakland looks pretty good, but the others... nah. Overkill designed, stupid looking mostly.
 
Of the choices given, the Nordy by far.

I was happy to see that someone made the point about the '51 P-bass as "the original" rather than the larger stock that we all know and love. I always liked the smaller stock of the '51.

As far as my current favorite...this is not a really elegant headstock, but there's something about it you just have to love:

2153878972_11ffb705e2_o.png
 
Weren't "Shmoon" from the "Lil' Abner" comic strip, not the much later Flintstones?
See: Invalid Link Removed

Also, to me, the Valenti headstock has a little gentle V at the end of the it.
Kinda a peace symbol or a V for victory ala Churchill...
See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Churchill_waves_to_crowds.jpg
I thought everyone knew that! :D :D :D

The Shmoo character appears to have originated with "Lil Abner" but it was also used with the Flintstones characters later on. That's where I remember it from

fredbarneyeshmoo.jpg



I guess one mans victory sign, is another mans horse head.
 
I give up. Apparently not very many of you read the original post and stayed on track. This thread has gotten so far off the original topic I think it may never get back. Now I know why elementary school teachers get so frustrated.:rolleyes:
If headstock SHAPE is so important, buy the one you think looks prettiest. It serves no other function except as manufacturer ID and as somewhere convenient to put trad type tuners. You're not going to get one brand with another's headstock and the rest of the instrument is far more important.
 
I give up. Apparently not very many of you read the original post and stayed on track. This thread has gotten so far off the original topic I think it may never get back. Now I know why elementary school teachers get so frustrated.:rolleyes:

I am an elementary school teacher (Music). I can assure you that you don't know. :D

You set up a poll and then wanted 5 additional questions answered.
Q: Why did it fail?
A: A teacher figures out the answer and fixes the problem.

IMHO, elementary school teachers are frustrated by lack of funding for
their schools and bad legislation.

BTW, Any headstock that is either of the two Fender shapes looks fine
to me, but I like the Sadowsky, Valenti, and Lakland shapes, too. For
me it is the instrument, not the headstock that matters in the end.

I have to assume the headstock shapes I like are my favorites because
of the sound and feel of instruments having those headstocks. I have
never bought an instrument because of its headstock shape, nor have I
ever decided not to buy because of the headstock shape.

Thought: maybe a poll that asks the one most important thing, followed by a second poll? :cool:
 
I give up. Apparently not very many of you read the original post and stayed on track. This thread has gotten so far off the original topic I think it may never get back. Now I know why elementary school teachers get so frustrated.:rolleyes:

And this is to say that you were actually harboring a different expectation when you started this particular thread? Anyone that has participated in TB for even a few days holds a clear understanding that any thread invoking even the slightest element of brand loyalty will carry with it a considerable amount of passion and resultant "left turns".
 
And this is to say that you were actually harboring a different expectation when you started this particular thread? Anyone that has participated in TB for even a few days holds a clear understanding that any thread invoking even the slightest element of brand loyalty will carry with it a considerable amount of passion and resultant "left turns".

*Tru dat!
 
I am an elementary school teacher (Music). I can assure you that you don't know. :D

*I come from a long line of school teachers. I have visited their classes and I agree. I don't know and definitely could not do what you do. I am just speaking as a student. Many times I have seen a teacher ask 2+2 and get an answer of purple. Then you watch as the rest of the class goes onto a five minute discussion on the color purple. It takes another ten minutes to get them refocused and the original question.

*A music teacher, huh? Ever wonder about job security? If things get much worse it will be music and art programs that go first. Music education is unnecessary anyway, right? I mean what good can come from developing a child's self esteem, sense of accomplishment and ability to work as part of a team? Oh yeah and don't forget giving that child a healthy respect for the arts. Who needs it! Is the sarcasm in my comments obvious or do I need to point it out?:D

You set up a poll and then wanted 5 additional questions answered.
Q: Why did it fail?
A: A teacher figures out the answer and fixes the problem.

*I remember being in Elementary school and having to write a paper on how to teach an alien to make a PBJ sandwich. All the kids wrote something to the nature of:

Step one: Get the Peanut butter out of the cupboard.
Step two: Get two slices of bread.

The teachers response to this was, "What is a cupboard? What is bread? This is an alien he doesn't know what these items even are. I guess I forgot those steps in setting up this poll.


IMHO, elementary school teachers are frustrated by lack of funding for
their schools and bad legislation.

*I will definitely second that. I was raised by two elementary school teachers and have a brother who is currently teaching in a public school. It is a shame that there isn't enough money to the point where teachers feel compelled to dip into their own pockets, and those pockets aren't very deep, to make sure the kids don't suffer. Also, with the way our state monitors a child's development it seems that it is more important that they can pass a test rather than actually have learned something.


BTW, Any headstock that is either of the two Fender shapes looks fine
to me, but I like the Sadowsky, Valenti, and Lakland shapes, too. For
me it is the instrument, not the headstock that matters in the end.


*Looks as though you read and understood the poll.


I have to assume the headstock shapes I like are my favorites because
of the sound and feel of instruments having those headstocks. I have
never bought an instrument because of its headstock shape, nor have I
ever decided not to buy because of the headstock shape.

*Again, exactly the answer I was looking for. It is your answer and actually pertains to the questions asked. Now was the rest of the class paying attention to Jim's answer?

Thought: maybe a poll that asks the one most important thing, followed by a second poll?
 

Latest posts