• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How long are your finger nails?!

How Long are your nails

  • French Tips. I'm a hand model for Givenchy

    Votes: 6 1.8%
  • Medium. Nail's about level with my calluses

    Votes: 45 13.5%
  • Short. I cut them babies back to the quick!!

    Votes: 266 79.6%
  • Was I supposed to pay attention to that too??!

    Votes: 17 5.1%

  • Total voters
    334
Been searching for a particular tone for a while and realised this particular's player's tone was partly due to his nails getting involved. I've always cut mine short. Have I been making a mistake?

My teacher kept them short on both hands. He'd let them grow longer on his plucking hand when the Rush Cover Band 'Solar Federation' that he was in would start up their gigging schedule to get the right sound for his bass playing Rush tunes.

I definitely keep them short for my fretting hand. I play with a ick, so I don't pay that much attention to my nails on my right hand.
 
Really short on my R (plucking) hand, especially the index and middle fingers. I clip all the way down to the nail bed, then file away the sharp edge. I can do some short fast runs with my ring finger getting a little action too, but not frequently. Still, for appearance, I keep them all really short on my R hand. On the L, not as critical, no affect on tone, so I usually just trim them up once a week or so to a length of ~ 1mm.

If I'm at band practice and I forgot to trim, I pluck a little more with the thumb side of my fingers so the nail doesn't get involved. But I prefer the tone with my finger at 90 degrees to the string so trimming my nails is one of the things I associate with packing my rig. Because when I inadvertently pluck with longer nails, I get a sharp, loud attack that just jumps out of the mix in the most cringeworthy way. It sounds awful and out of place, and I prefer my clams to be subtle and really hard to hear, not just jumping out at you like that!

If I were going for that tone, I would keep them longer and turn down a little, as when I use a pick.
 
I pluck bass strings with index and middle fingers, so they're cut all the way back,

but I pluck guitar using my nails, so I developed skill picking guitar with my thumb and ring finger only, and I've gotten good at it, sounds like I'm using my middle finger, as well.

Now that I'm doing the band thing, I'm strictly bass and keep them all cut back. :)
 
I keep mine super short. I slap a ton and and find that the nails grab the string and make it sound super harsh. It also scratches up your bass when you pop. Besides it just makes for easier fretting when you dont have nails getting in the way
 
  • Like
Reactions: DrThumpenstein