What are all the P&W bands?
Percussion and Wanking.
pretty much modern metal
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
What are all the P&W bands?
Percussion and Wanking.
pretty much modern metal![]()
I'm in a three piece 4 person band, and have learned a lot from the time I've been with them.
The reason I ask is, I love the bass. I love playing the bass. But I don't ever see myself ever playing with others in a band due to certain things in my life. Therefore I'm limited to just playing bass at home, alone.
The bass is not really made as a "solo" instrument. Yes, there are individuals out there that use it for solo work as with just about any instrument, but it's generally regarded as an instrument that's part of a group. Not only that, but it seems to be the general consensus of a lot of other bassist that soloing on a bass is "wanking" and is frowned upon (though I can't for the life of me understand why). To listen to some guys, the bass player should ONLY play root notes and if anything extra is played then "he's not doing his part in the band correctly" or again, he's "wanking".
ANYWAY, back to the topic. How many out there actually play in a band? If not, do you still just play the bass at home? How do you play, solo or do you always just play along with your favorite songs? It's hard for me to justify laying out the cash for a bass, a bass amp and cabs only to just play along to "Ramble On" by Zeppelin (though, it's pretty fun).
I'm stuck at a crossroads, should I instead invest in learning the guitar or piano as their much more expressive. But I'm always drawn back to the sound of the bass. I dig the bass. When listening to music I'm always drawn first to the bass line.
i'm just curious as to your reasoning for not wanting to play in a band.
anecdote: my little brother, who's a prog/math/experimental music genius went through a phase of not wanting to play with anyone because he had gotten burned bad a few times with past bands. and he doesn't really need anyone, he knows how to mix, master, distribute his music, he's entirely self-contained. however, when last i spoke with him, he lamented the loss of community, fellowship, and creative associated with his choice to become a one-man band. he's now looking for other musicians.
i'm in 4 outfits currently.
